The term “estate tax planning” has always been a little bit of an oxymoron to me. That’s because you cannot really plan the main event— that being the time you are going to die.
There is no question that if we had a crystal ball and knew exactly when a person was going to go, it would be much easier to plan for their estate taxes. Especially with the new tax law that eliminates the estate tax in 10 years. Hooray! But what if you are going to die in five years? Big problems.
If you have recently been in the process of revising or for the first time creating your estate plan or you are thinking about it in the near future, you need to pay close attention to the changes that have been made in the Economic Growth and Tax Relief Reconciliation Act of 2001.
For many decades, the tax law has provided for a uniform system of gift and estate taxation. Under that system, all transfers throughout a person’s life and death were taxed on the same tax scale. Now that concept has been abandoned. While the estate tax is eventually eliminated, the gift tax will remain.
This concept will greatly change the time-valued principle that estate planners have used of trying to transfer assets to taxpayersâ heirs before they die, in order to reduce estate taxes.
This created a great dilemma for many taxpayers: Should they give assets to their children as soon as possible to get the maximum estate-tax savings possible and risk “spoiling” them by making them wealthy without having to work for it? To solve this problem, many planning devices have been devised over the years to help taxpayers get assets out of their estates without giving up total control or the benefits from those assets. Now, without an estate tax, the taxpayer would, from a tax perspective, probably never want to make a taxable gift and those devices would generally serve no tax purpose under the new tax law.
To make matters worse, 10 years from now when the estate tax is fully repealed, the provisions of this tax act expire. Unless a future congress and president agree to a continuation of the provisions of the bill, the estate tax may come back after ten years. Also, there is no guarantee that even before the ten years are up that Congress may not see fit to make some changes or modifications in the provisions of the act.
What is a person to do amid all of this uncertainty? I think it is important for people to remember one basic elementary fact that a lot of people forget in doing estate planning. So much of estate planning is geared around tax savings, whereas the most important thing to always consider is who is going to be in control of your assets.
I see many estate plans that work very efficiently for taxes but totally frustrate the taxpayersâ plans for who should benefit from and be able to utilize the assets after they die because they are controlled by third parties or people they did not really intend to have control.
For example, I once had a client who gave what at the time of his death was a very generous provision in his will establishing a trust from which his wife could draw a fixed amount of income. At the time it was considered to be very generous, with the balance going to his two grandchildren. The purpose of this, of course, was to make sure that the assets were not taxed in his wife’s estate but would pass to the grandchildren before the estate tax would have to be paid again.
Unfortunately, 30 years after his death, the fixed income that was allocable to his wife was a pittance and the grandchildren, who had totally estranged themselves from the family except to collect their annual checks from the trust. They were receiving more than $100,000 a year each, and then ultimately received all of the assets after his spouse died.
If you are planning to make any taxable gifts or irrevocable transfers of property, you may want to reconsider. There may be some unusual situations where this might be advisable, but given the fact that the estate tax is scheduled to be repealed, there seem to be few justifications for making taxable gifts at this time, or to give up control of property through other vehicles such as irrevocable trusts while you are still alive.
This has now become an area that is so complex and filled with so many variables that it really behooves a serious candidate for estate planning to seek the advise of someone who is truly competent and well-versed in the tax law, especially since the rules seem to be changing almost every year and will, by necessity change within the next 10 years.
Dennis V. King, a partner in King, King, Alleman and Jensen ( 818-848-5585 ), lives in Santa Clarita and specializes in personal and business financial planning. “It’s Your Money” appears Mondays and rotates among SCV financial professionals.
