As I was pondering this week’s commentary, a fax came across my desk. It was the financial statement of a company that was looking for investors.
Company representatives had met with me and my client previously and discussed the hot idea that was going to make us all a ton of money on a very and “safe” investment.
As I looked over the balance sheet, I couldn’t believe my eyes. The company had less than $25,000 in cash, virtually no other assets, liabilities totaling $2.25 million, and had already lost more than $5 million. The current “burn rate” — that is, the amount of money the company was spending each month in excess of revenues— was $200,000.
The people had asked for $500,000 to carry them just a couple of months until they could get their money from a “direct public offering” (DPO). A DPO is an offering made directly to the public through an Internet Web site or some other type of direct solicitation without going through a broker or a regular underwriter.
You might ask what is so bad about this, if it really is a great investment idea and the people have a great program and maybe they will get funded and everyone will get rich.
It could happen, and if we all go to Las Vegas and put $200,000 on the boxcars at the crap table and it hits we will do very well, too. But the odds are not very good.
There seems to be a massive army of so-called investment advisors who claim to have some special knowledge or clever idea and they are going to let you in on it. They talk such a good story that the common investor has a feeling that he is really an idiot if he doesn’t invest his hard-earned cash in these wild ideas and programs.
The fact is, most of the cash these people raise goes to pay their salary and expenses.
A couple of years ago, one of my more successful but more elderly clients called me just to inquire what his tax liability would be, because he wanted to put some money into an investment. He hadn’t spoken to me at all about the investment. When I started to question him about it, he seemed a bit irritated but agreed to bring over the pamphlet he had.
When he brought it over I found out that he had received the pamphlet from a supervisor of a house-painting crew that had been working on his home. Apparently, the supervisor had run across this investment opportunity and was quite excited about it, and had put his own money into it and, of course, his mother’s and his mother-in-law ’s money, too.
My client felt that if this man had put his mother’s and mother-in-law ’s money into the investment, that it must be a good deal, and that he must know what he was talking about, so he was ready to write the man a $150,000 check to get him into it.
I asked him to please hold off for a while so that I could do a bit of investigation.
He seemed to think it was a waste of time, but he let me do some checking. It didn’t take me long to discover some interesting things. The deal involved buying airtime for infomercials, and this company was supposed to produce a lot of infomercials that would generate large profits and huge returns to the investors. Then, of course, the company would go public, and the investors would get a chance to be in on the ground floor and were promised fabulous riches.
I soon learned that the legitimate companies that this investment group claimed to work with, disavowed all knowledge of any contracts with the company, were very closed-mouthed , and refused to divulge much information.
I finally contacted the bunko personnel at the local police department, who contacted some of their friends and found out the Federal Trade Commission was investigating this business deal and did not want to say much about it at the time— but urged me to advise my client not to get in it.
Two weeks later there were headlines in the newspapers reporting that the federal crackdown on the scam about which my client had been approached, had conned literally thousands of people out of millions of dollars.
While these two examples have great differences, they often lead to the same result: The investor loses money.
In the first one, the people presenting the investment opportunity had genuine and sincere hopes that their investment would make money and were working hard toward that end. They are in a pretty hopeless situation, but they sincerely expected to find the pot of gold at the end of the rainbow.
The second case was a clear case of intentional fraud to take the investors’ money.
But even though the promoters of the infomercial scam were absolute crooks, it has been my experience that the first type of investment promoter is actually the more dangerous!
The scariest type of con is the one who believes his own story. That is the individual who has such a great idea that he knows it will work if he can just get enough people on board with him, giving him the money to make it happen. That type of person is likely to present whatever story he can to get the money because he knows once the money is in, the project will be successful and everyone will be happy and he will be able to cover whatever tracks he left in getting there.
There is a curious aspect to financial scams. When it’s all over and we’re able to look back with 20-20 hindsight, it seems easy to see what was going on from the very inception, and absolutely ludicrous that anyone would have ever gotten into the scam.
However, at the front end, when you are presented with these opportunities, there is so much emotion and excitement about the profit potential that there is no clear vision of the disasters that lie ahead.
That is why it is so important to have some strict investment rules for yourself, and the discipline to follow through with them.
While there are many signposts to tip one off to the typical scam artist, there are a few basic things that should always be remembered:
• The basic “too good to be true” doctrine: If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.
• Always know who is behind the investment program. If it is someone new to you, it is well worth the time and money to actually do a background investigation on the principles behind the organization. It is amazing how many of these people have had prior fraud convictions or other financial problems that show up very quickly in any type of background check.
• Make sure the people working the project have an actual financial stake in it. Many times, people without money get an idea and want to work a project and get investors to come in as the money partner. As soon as the project starts to get difficult and the worker partner gets another job offer, he takes the new job and the investor is left with an operation that he does not understand which is usually in financial difficulty and then is faced with the dilemma of putting more into the project and finding people to run it to make it viable or to walk away and lose everything.
• Invest only in projects where you really understand what is being done.
• Beware of “opportunities” that must be consummated immediately. If the promoter won’t give you time to thoroughly investigate the investment— walk or run away.
Finally, as a sort of a pervasive rule, I never forget the wise counsel given to me by one of my most successful clients. He said, “Ultimately, the decisions you make about people are much more important than the decisions you make about things.”
The point is, there are thousands of different businesses that are very successful and provide great returns to their investors if they are managed properly and run by honest people with integrity who will really perform as they say they will.
On the other hand, there are tens of thousands who want money so badly that they would be glad to sell you the clear, blue sky. So watch carefully whom you deal with. Don’t be a sucker.
Dennis V. King, a partner in King, King, Alleman and Jensen ( 818-848-5585 ), lives in Santa Clarita and specializes in personal and business financial planning. “It’s Your Money” appears Mondays and rotates among SCV financial professionals.
