Only in a family business would an employee receive a raise because his wife, who just gave birth to the CEO’s granddaughter,
decided not to go back to work.
Only in a family business would two employees, who happen to be siblings, receive equal pay regardless of their contributions to the organization.
It’s natural for parents to be concerned about the welfare of their children, but what impact do compensation decisions have on other family members who work in the business? What about non-family employees?
Placing personal needs over job performance in setting compensation can cause tension, resentment, and conflict. On the other hand, basing pay strictly on job contribution can raise problems of its own. Consider the youngest child in a middle-management position who resents her older siblings’ executive salaries and perks.
In a family business, compensation problems often arise when pay is used to serve some purpose other than encouraging professional growth and rewarding job performance.
To avoid these problems, a family business needs a compensation plan, and the first step is to articulate a compensation philosophy. Will the compensation plan focus on profits and shareholder value? Productivity, efficiency, and quality? Customer service? By establishing the guiding values, principles and goals of the compensation system, the business avoids the difficulty of developing compensation packages on a case-by-case basis.
One of the most important decisions the business must make is whether to adopt the “market” approach to compensation, where employees are paid based on the relative importance and difficulty of their jobs. Salaries and benefits are determined based on market data from comparable jobs at comparable companies. The advantages of the market approach are that it’s fair, it’s readily understood by employees and shareholders, and it helps remove emotional concerns from the equation.
At the same time, a shift to the market approach can stir up all sorts of tensions for a family business with a long-standing , albeit inequitable, compensation hierarchy.
The market approach may appeal to your sense of fairness, but there may also be advantages to paying family members equally. When several siblings with equal ownership stakes work together in the business, for example, equal pay may promote teamwork and ultimately help the business achieve its goals. This approach may not be workable, however, when management includes multiple family members of different ages and generations as well as non-family members.
There’s no single compensation formula that works for every family business. Each company must design a plan that’s tailored to fit its particular makeup and to help achieve its objectives.
For many organizations, a strict market approach is most effective. For others, it may be appropriate to place family needs above business needs.
Some family businesses have found that a hybrid approach provides the best of both worlds: Market data is used to set base salaries, with bonuses tied to family status. Family members active in management may receive additional salary for serving on an executive committee. Breaking down compensation into components helps other employees compare “apples to apples” when evaluating their own compensation.
A compensation plan in a family business has little chance of succeeding without an “open book” policy regarding compensation. Shareholders, employees, and other interested parties need to understand the compensation policy and how it will help the business succeed.
Perhaps the best argument for airing your compensation plan is this: If you’re comfortable sharing the details of the plan, chances are good that it will be perceived as fair.
Dennis V. King, a partner in King, King, Alleman and Jensen ( 818-848-5585 ), lives in Santa Clarita and specializes in personal and business financial planning. “It’s Your Money” appears Mondays and rotates among SCV financial professionals.
