ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

It’s Your Money

Do S&P 500 funds make sense?

By now I am sure most of you have heard the investment mantra:

“Buy S&P 500 index mutual funds— over time you are better off.” I am not so sure.

A compelling claim for investing in an S&P 500 Index fund is that it mirrors the overall stock market. In other words, it is well diversified. A basic tenet of investing is that investors should maintain a well diversified portfolio. An S&P 500 Index fund id purported to meet that criteria.

The S&P 500 Index, on which the Index funds are based, is not as diversified as we are led to believe. The S&P stock index is a “ market-cap ” weighted index. This means that the greater the relative value of a company in terms of its outstanding stock, the greater will be its relative weighting in the S&P 500 index.

For example, if a company’s total outstanding stock has doubled in value and is now equal to 10 percent of the total value of the entire S&P 500 stocks, then 10 percent of the S&P 500 Index fund needs to be allocated to that one company— whereas before the big jump in stock price, only 5 percent of the index fund was so allocated.

S&P 500 Stock Index funds are structured to mirror the S&P 500 Stock Index. If a company’s stock weighting in the index was 5 percent, then 5 percent of money’s invested in an S&P 500 Index fund would be used to purchase that company’s stock.

Did you know:

• Last year, only 31 stocks accounted for all the S&P 500’s 21 percent gain. By contrast, in 1995, 341 stocks were responsible for the index’s 37.6 percent climb.

• The 10 largest stock holdings now represent 25 percent of the total market value of the S&P 500.

• High-priced technology stocks now account for about one-third of the S&P 500’s total value, up from about 9 percent just 10 years ago.

Well diversified? The Index is not nearly as diversified as it used to be and neither are the funds which mirror the Index.

Another compelling claim is that actively managed funds cannot beat the overall stock market over time. So there is no reason to put your money anywhere other than the S&P 500 Index fund.

From 1993 to 1998, the S&P 500 Index did outperform the majority of managed funds. We now find that is changing: Actively managed funds are once again beating the S&P 500 stock index in terms of performance.

According to Morningstar Inc., nearly two-thirds of diversified mutual funds investing in U.S. stocks are outperforming S&P 500 index funds this year. This is a far cry from three years ago when only 11 percent of mutual fund managers beat the index.

What has changed? The self-fulfilling prophecy that we had witnessed over the past six years stopped being self-fulfilling . Index funds grew from almost nothing in the early 1990s to about $230 billion as of the end of last quarter.

The 500 companies that make up the S&P 500 Index were the beneficiaries of a huge cash infusion which persisted through out the mid 1990s. As money flowed into the index funds, the S&P 500 stock index went up. With more people chanting the “S&P 500” mantra after seeing S&P 500 index performance, even more money was attracted into the index funds, thus driving up the index even more— including the prices of the stocks that make up the S&P 500 Index.

The stocks that comprise the S&P 500 eventually became significantly overpriced compared to the market as a whole. Now, we see investment dollars flowing to more attractive investments.

The old investment adage of “buy low, sell high” tends to work in reverse when investing in the S&P 500 Index. Due to the way that the S&P 500 Index is computed, more invested dollars end up being allocated to stock of overpriced companies, with fewer invested dollars being allocated to underpriced companies.

To expand on the example above:

Let’s say that the rise in that company’s stock value wasn’t really justified. In other words, it was overpriced. Would you want 10 percent of your investment dollars being invested in an overpriced stock? (Or more, assuming that there are other companies in the S&P 500 in similar situations?) Would you not want more of your dollars being invested in undervalued companies with a greater chance of appreciation?

Cisco, General Electric, and Coca Cola all have price-earnings ratios considered to be quite high by traditional market standards, and they represent an extremely large portion of the S&P 500 Index pie. By virtue of their size, more index invested dollars will be invested in the above companies (thought to be overpriced by some) than would be invested in more reasonably priced companies in that same index.

Given the above concerns about investing in index funds, you may find that an S&P 500 Index fund is not the panacea that you once thought.

D. Frank Norton, CPA, MBA, CFP, is a money manager and financial planner in Santa Clarita. “It’s Your Money” appears on Mondays and rotates among SCV financial professionals.

← Back to 2000

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-df:/business/money/0900/091100a.html.
System
date-file pages (/desk/MMYY/MMDDYY.html)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 859 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
datefile:START_STORY
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • url:datefile_business
  • text:valley_names [2 distinct/2 mentions: Santa Clarita, SCV]
  • byline:named_writer_no_wire_credit [By D. Frank Norton]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 7, national 0