Following the horrific events of Sept. 11, a new economic dynamic cast its constraining net over this nation.
CBS MarketWatch reported last Friday, after the market close, that $1.4 trillion was lost in the stock market in the past week. It also reported that the Dow Jones average lost 14.3 percent, or 1,367 points— the worst one-week decline for the Dow since the Great Depression.
The accompanying chart from The-Street.com reveals that investors in the market since September 1998 have, as a whole, ended up at valuations equal to about where they started. Those who invested since then... well, I would hate to guess where they are now.
We’ve read that Northwest Airlines is laying off 10,000 people— 20 percent of the workforce— following other announced layoffs from Boeing and other airlines. More corporations are reducing their earnings forecasts and, in some instances, increasing their loss forecasts.
The Conference Board released a survey Friday indicating that almost half of all Americans believe the terrorist attacks will throw the country into recession.
Will the last bastion of support for this economy, the consumer, continue to spend in light of this dower economic outlook, coupled with report after report of more people being laid off? I think not.
I haven’t even touched on what impact a protracted war against terrorism, and all of its potential side effects, might have on this economy.
I am sure, by the time you read this, that you already will have been sufficiently depressed from reading the Sunday newspaper headlines. You certainly don’t need any more depressing news... but what you do need is hope to replace despair, and a rational perspective to replace blind, irrational panic.
Buy straw hats in winter
Consider the following:
Almost without exception, when we make investment decisions based on our emotions— whether they’re based on greed or fear— we end up making wrong decisions. Emotional investors tend to invest at the top of investment cycles and sell at the bottom of investment cycles. Do you think we are closer to a market top or a market bottom?
There is $6 trillion sitting in bank certificates of deposit, savings accounts, money market funds and other short-term investment assets, as reported last Thursday by Barry Evans, Chief Fixed Income Officer at John Hancock Funds. The interest rates that this money is earning have plunged to levels not seen in years and can’t be very attractive to investors. Much of this money is poised to come back into the stock market.
Although the economy is currently in the intensive-care unit, history has shown that it hasn’t stayed there for long. A great deal of effort is now going into reviving this economy, such as:
• The Federal Reserve Board lowered short term interest rates again this past week by 1/2 percent, down to 3 percent. Many believe short-term rates will be lowered to 2.5 percent by the end of the year. The Fed has also provided a tremendous amount of liquidity to our nation’s banks, to allow them to lend more at much lower rates.
• USA Today reported last Friday that 30-year fixed mortgage rates are down to 6.8 percent and 15-year fixed rates are down to 6.3 percent. As more people refinance their existing mortgages, more discretionary dollars will be left in their pockets each month, which can have a dramatic impact on this economy.
• Income tax rate reductions, already in place, will continue to provide stimulus for this economy. Congress and the President are already talking about further tax cuts, including a lowering of capital gains tax rates.
• Jumps in unemployment have tended to be a lagging indicator of the economy, not a leading indicator. In past economic downturns, the economy had already started its recovery, when rising layoffs were occurring.
• The executive branch has been given the green light to open up the money vaults and provide fiscal stimulus to the economy.
You incur real losses only when you sell. Right now, many are sitting on some pretty significant paper losses. If you should now liquidate and go to the sidelines, you will have converted a paper loss to a real loss.
And the income tax laws are no help... you can deduct only $3,000 in capital losses in excess of capital gains each year. If your investment funds are in IRAs or pension plans, none of the losses would be deductible. What a bummer!
So what do you do?
Since it is difficult to time or predict this market, I would not be a heavy seller of stocks at this time. In fact, for those with a long-term perspective beyond next week, month, or year, this may be one of the best times to buy stocks in many years. I truly believe it would be like buying straw hats in winter. To paraphrase Warren Buffet, the ideal time to buy is when others are fearful. Others are certainly fearful now.
I believe we could potentially see another 10-percent-or-so decrease in stock prices over the next few weeks as others join in the panic. (If that scenario bothers you, then you shouldn’t be invested in the stock market in the first place). Then, I believe the irrepressible nature of the market will again reassert itself as the economy and corporations start to respond to the tremendous economic stimulus unleashed over the last several months, as well as just recently.
Our economy and stock market are resilient and will heal. And so will you.
D. Frank Norton, CPA, MBA, CFP, is a money manager and financial planner in Santa Clarita. “It’s Your Money” appears on Mondays and rotates among SCV financial professionals.
