I am frequently asked about the net benefits of spending money on something that’s tax deductible. The first rule I always cite is to “refrain from making an unwise economic expenditure to avoid tax.”
Tax savings are less than 100 percent.
If we lived in an economy whose tax rate exceeded 100 percent, the decision would be easy. But in 1999, for example, the married-filing-jointly federal tax rates on taxable income are 15 percent, 28 percent, 31 percent, 36 percent and 39.5 percent. Under this tax structure, you’ll never get back in taxes what you lose economically. And the lower you are on the tax bracket scale, the less sense it makes to make an unwise economic expenditure to save tax dollars.
Your incremental tax rate counts.
The second rule is to “apply your additional deduction to your incremental tax rate.”
For example, 1999’s 28 percent tax bracket for married-filing-jointly lies in between $40,030 and $104,050 of taxable income. If your taxable income is in the middle of that bracket, then most newly devised tax deductions will save you 28 percent in taxes.
If you are barely into the 28 percent bracket, then a tax deduction may be partially in the 28 percent and the 15 percent brackets. This could reduce your overall tax savings on that new deduction to somewhere in between 15 percent and 28 percent.
Tax exempt interest investments may not be worth it.
Some taxpayers will do anything to avoid incurring income tax. My third rule is, “the public should look for the best place to earn the highest rate of return on their investment and let their tax consultants worry about the tax effect.”
Example: If you can invest in a secure interest-bearing document paying 10 percent, your after-tax benefit will equal 7.2 percent, assuming you are in the 28 percent federal income tax bracket. Should you then consider a tax-exempt instrument paying 5 percent?
On the other hand, if you can find only a regular investment paying 2 percent above the tax-exempt instrument, then the purchase of a tax-exempt instrument may be a worthwhile investment after all else is considered.
Roth IRA versus buying a home:
A young man recently asked me about the benefits of investing in a Roth IRA. I asked him if he owned a home. He didn’t.
I told him a Roth IRA was a retirement investment instrument, and that the loss of tax benefits and penalties surrounding it were designed to keep it that way.
I told him that if he bought a home in an area with good upside market potential, it might give him the tax-sheltered appreciation he wants, and more flexibility.
There is a lot to consider here, including when he would be able to buy his first home, the tax deductions for mortgage interest and property taxes, the other non-deductible costs of owning a home, the alternative cost of renting, and the home’s realistic potential for market value gain.
Nonetheless, just a small percentage of homeowners have been sorry they bought their homes.
A leased automobile can beat a purchase in business.
Disregarding the tax implications for the moment, if you are going to lease an automobile instead of buying it, the economics of that decision may be more important than the tax implications.
For tax purposes, the business portion of vehicle expenses includes depreciation at a limited rate, interest on the vehicle loan, and vehicle operating expenses. If you lease, the lease payment expenses take the place of the depreciation and the interest deductions.
In looking at the tax difference, the lease method usually allows for a quicker write-off . The more expensive the automobile, the better the lease advantage.
But it’s not a huge advantage, so make sure your lease compares equally with the purchase before you sign the agreement.
Mike Daney is a Valencia resident and a Certified Public Accountant with a practice in Newhall. “It’s Your Money” appears Mondays and rotates among SCV financial professionals.
More "It's Your Money" Columns
