A column appeared in this newspaper a couple of weeks ago which presented a negative picture about investing in deferred annuities.
The column basically said there are very few instances when it would be appropriate to invest in a deferred annuity.
Today’s column will present a differing opinion.
First, what is a deferred annuity? Deferred annuities are offered by insurance companies. They allow investors to defer any taxable income earned by the dollars invested until investors should decide to withdraw some or all of their funds. At the time of withdrawal, any untaxed income withdrawn will be taxed at ordinary income tax rates.
There are two types of deferred annuities: fixed and variable annuities.
1. Fixed annuities. The principal invested is guaranteed by the insurance company. Interest is earned on the money invested at a fixed rate for either one or more years. Once the fixed interest rate period has expired, the interest rate can be adjusted by the insurance company to reflect changing market conditions, and to cover changing costs that the insurance company is incurring.
2. Variable annuities. The insurance company does not guarantee the principal. Instead, the insurance company will typically offer a number of different investment portfolios managed by portfolio managers from well known mutual fund companies. The investment risk is passed on to the investor.
Deferred annuities are definitely not for everyone. It is not a short-term investment. Someone wanting to withdraw his or her funds within a few years of investing may find:
• Withdrawals subject to early withdrawal penalties assessed by the insurance company; and
• Premature distribution penalties on income assessed by the IRS and state if the investor is not yet 59 1/2 years old.
Deferred annuities are definitely designed as investment vehicles for tax deferral until or during retirement.
Now, let me address some of the objections concerning deferred annuities which were listed by my fellow columnist:
“Too expensive.” I have found that fixed annuities offered by reputable insurance companies offer interest rates which are comparable or better than interest rates offered by banks and savings institutions.
With variable annuities, when we compare the costs of investing directly in mutual funds versus investing in similarly managed portfolios within in variable annuities, the annual costs will be anywhere from 1/2 percent to 1.2 percent greater inside a variable annuity. For some, this would be too costly, for others well worth the cost to defer the taxation on the earnings.
“Offers mediocre insurance coverage.” The primary purpose of annuities is to offer tax deferral, not insurance coverage.
“Restricts investment to so-so quasi-mutual fund companies.” Most insurance companies go out of their way to entice superb fund managers to provide their services to variable annuity investors.
One variable annuity that I just recently invested in offers 48 different investment options including portfolios managed by Janus, Invesco, Alger, Aim, Rydex, Pimco and others. I wouldn’t call these portfolios or fund companies “ so-so .”
“Growth taxed at ordinary income tax rates on withdrawal.” If you were to invest in a typical growth mutual fund outside of an annuity, you would find that the growth would typically be taxed at capital gains tax rates which are lower than ordinary tax rates. Why would anyone invest in a variable annuity only to incur taxes at ordinary tax rates down the road instead of ordinary tax rates?
“Flexibility to move funds from one or more portfolios to different portfolios without creating a taxable event.” If an investor moves money between funds frequently, that investor will find that short term capital gains (which are taxed at ordinary tax rates) may be incurred each time a move is made. Why not place those same funds in an annuity to accomplish the same exchanges but without current taxation at ordinary tax rates?
You control when the earnings inside an annuity get taxed. For those who own mutual funds directly, you will probably be seeing significant long and short term capital gains being distributed and taxed to you this year. And you never pulled any money out! All such income would not be taxed inside an annuity until you decide to pull the money out.
“Lack liquidity.” As mentioned before, if you decide to pull the funds out early, there may be early withdrawal penalties assessed by the insurance company as well as tax penalties.
“Commissions paid to salesmen.” Yes, salesmen do get paid by insurance companies for business brought to them. So do securities brokers who sell stocks, mutual funds, etc. “ No-load ” variable annuities are available, similar to “ no-load ” mutual funds, where the sales cost is minimal.
Yes, there are some valid reasons for investing in deferred annuities when the alternative investment is in some taxable investment vehicle.
D. Frank Norton, CPA, MBA, CFP, is a money manager and financial planner in Santa Clarita. “It’s Your Money” appears on Mondays and rotates among SCV financial professionals.
