Many investors are seeing the stock market indexes again reach double-digit returns after the run-up in stock prices of the last couple of weeks.
However, when investors then take a look at their own mutual fund portfolios, many find that their funds’ performance has been sadly lagging, often showing little, if any, appreciation.
Frank Norton
It's Your Money
The reasons are two-fold :
• Investors have stayed invested in conservative, large-company blue-chip stock funds which have lagged behind the overall market in performance.
Scanning the mutual funds section in the Wall Street Journal, I see many large-company equity income funds and balanced funds which are up only a few percentage points for the year. These are the same funds which have seen very acceptable double-digit returns each year for the past three years.
• Conservative investors have maintained a large allocation of their investment dollars in bond funds, which have really taken a beating this year so far. The reason for this beating is the rapid rise in long-term interest rates, from about 4.9 percent at the beginning of the year to well over 6 percent today (30 year treasury bond rates).
Sooo... Where should you consider putting your money now?
I recently attended a conference in Boston where I had a chance to visit with a number of respected mutual fund managers and market analysts. I came away with the following potential areas of opportunity: financial stocks; health care stocks; small to mid-cap technology stocks; and small-cap (company) stocks.
Small company stocks
First, a definition: Small-cap stocks are those whose market capitalizations (market value of the company) are less than $1 billion.
Why bother with small-cap stocks? The accompanying table, which looks at asset returns from 1974 to 1998, should shed some light.
We see that over the long periods of time, small-cap stocks have outperformed other major asset categories.
Why small-cap stocks now? As of the end of this last quarter, small company stocks were extremely undervalued in comparison to large-cap stocks. If we look at relative price-earnings (P/E) ratios of large-cap stocks as compared to small-cap stocks, we find that large-cap stock P/E ratios have historically been about 65 percent of small-cap stock P/E ratios.
Given the same earnings per share for a large-cap stock and a small-cap stock, the large-cap stock would be trading at prices some 35 percent lower than the small-cap stock.
At the end of September, small-cap stocks were trading at P/E ratios about equal to the P/E ratios of large-cap stocks. If we can assume that small companies as a whole tend to grow at much greater rates when compared to large companies, then much higher P/E ratios would be (and have been) justified.
A word of caution: Small-cap stocks tend to be much more volatile. Most investors would want to have a good, diversified portfolio to spread out the risk. Small-cap mutual funds accomplish that. Take a look.
D. Frank Norton, CPA, MBA, CFP, is a money manager and financial planner in Santa Clarita. To receive Mr. Norton’s newsletter with more investment advice, contact him through The Signal at 259-1234 ext. 237 or [email protected] . “It’s Your Money” appears on Mondays and rotates among SCV financial professionals.
