I'm for aggressive journalism photography. Few things rile me more than the passive newspaper photo. A forest fire rages and all you, the reader, see is an out-of-focus shoulder and a raincoat. One of the biggest scams we, the media, have pulled on you public schmucks is that we've pretty much have been running the same three sports photos for 50 years. In basketball, it's the shot of eight armpits going for a rebound. For football, it's the same three helmets running an end-around. Baseball? Guy at the plate, swinging. DiMaggio or Billie in Little League — as far as the camera is concerned, it's the same guy.
It's a tough profession, taking pictures for a paper. You arrive at a traffic accident. You might find a dead baby, screaming parent, an emotionally shattered Highway Patrolman. As a press photographer, it's not your job to tell the best story of that moment in time. It's your duty.
Why?
Ethically, this very act of camera lens intrusion may save a life down the line. That photo might be the memory someone recalls which keeps them from having that one last drink or whispers a voice of caution to not run a red light.
Having said all that, I am in favor of Senator Dianne Feinstein's bill to curb paparazzi.
Yes. I realize it's a shallow election year issue to get her in front of some of the very cameras she wants if not outlawed, at least disciplined.
Of all people, I have Monica Lewinsky to thank for my anti-Worst Case Scenario shutterbug position.
I was watching the news yesterday morning and through the irony of watching a paparazzo film the paparazzi, I witnessed a journa-mob surround the legendary intern. Monica walked from a building. Cameramen swarmed to wall her in. She literally couldn't move. Nervously, she raised her hand to brush away some hair and a photographer grabbed her arm, held it down and wouldn't let it go. As he roughly gripped her wrist, the photographer shoved his camera into her face, clicking away.
Call me medieval, but I think the fellow ought to be horsewhipped.
The thing is, no person in the media needs to literally attack anyone to get a good picture. The rankest amateur with an off-the-shelf camera can get a zoom lens that takes really good pictures from at least — at least — 25 feet away.
The predictable and tired arguments of the ACLU — who seem to take an anarchistic, liberty without license or consequence stance on most matters — is that the First Amendment will be seriously damaged if you restrict camera Nazis from forming human hyena packs and gnawing at their still-living models.
I have yet to hear any stop-the-presses quote — or a quote, period — offered to the world from sticking a lens up someone's nose. And the photos themselves — they're more about the media mobbing the subject than the subject itself.
This mosh pit mob mentality of the photo media — it's ugly. It has nothing to do with freedom of the press or dissemination of information. The famous, the best or even the worst of us — no one deserves to be screamed at, shoved or mobbed. To brush off this overt aggression on our liberty with the whiny, "I'm just doing my job" is the same tired justification used for all manner of crimes of those in power. To hide behind the Constitution is smarmy. The founding fathers had nobler things in mind when they wrote it.
Aggressive, honest press photography? Yes. Please. Feeding frenzy journalism, no.
* * *
John Boston's Mr. Santa Clarita Valley columns appear Wednesdays through Saturdays. His Best of Boston columns appear Mondays. This column originally appeared Feb. 19, 1998. To reach Boston, dial 259-1234, ext. 242.
