“I am sitting in the smallest room in the house. I have your review in front of me. Soon it will be behind me.”
— Max Reger, 1902
Beloved critic, family man, community supporter and perhaps Hollywood’s most respected voice of taste and conscience in the film industry, David Manning died yesterday. We think he was 13.
At least he wrote like he was.
While many film critics tire the 21st century sensibility by using far too many words, Manning’s voice was a refreshing haiku. Who can ever forget his haunting condensation of the Rob Schneider’s answer to “Schindler’s List,” — “The Animal?”
Quoth Schneider: “Another Winner!”
Another Winner! Breath-taking in its brevity. And who would have thought to add an exclamation point at the end!
There were those foul critics of Manning’s work. The pointy-head intellectuals of Newsweek magazine tried to besmirch his genius, suggesting, in their investigative reporting, that he was an in-house toady and liar. Oh how the media attempts to re-invent Watergate. Poor Mr. Manning. Career Dead. Cold in his grave. And Newsweek is spreading the rumor that he doesn’t even exist.
Newsweek tried to point out that David Manning was an employee of Sony Pictures— producers of the universally-panned film, “The Animal.” Newsweek pried where no medium should. They called The Ridgefield Press, the Connecticut weekly newspaper where Mr. Manning was allegedly headquartered.
Poor, mistrusting Newsweek. How empty their soul must be to see the world through such suspicious eyes. Newsweek reported that the saintly Mr. Manning did not even exist and that he was a stealth employee of Sony. That every time Sony had a bomb of a film to release, Mr. Manning would get on the Internet with fawning praise (Like, “Another Winner!”). Sony, in turn, would run Mr. Manning’s quote on their movie ads across America, duping an unsuspecting public into attending otherwise shlocky Hollywood fare.
Newsweek pointed out that Mr. Manning had a track record of salivating over such self-exploding flicks as, “Hollow Man” and “Vertical Limit.” That, as a Sony representative, the faux film reviewer Mr. Manning had praised Heath Ledger, who stars in the summer box office extravaganza, “A Knight’s Tale” as: “... this year’s hottest new star!”
Again, what genius. Five words and an exclamation point.
Poor Mr. Manning, critic extraordinaire, we hardly knew thee. Even his newspaper abandoned him in his darkest hour, noting, “We never heard of the guy.” They said they had no idea their newspaper’s name was fraudulently being used in a national advertising campaign.
Now, the Connecticutt attorney general is currently coming up with his own prose for the non-existant Manning: “Jail Time!” In Hartford, the state’s top attorney, Richard Blumenthal, says he’s starting a criminal probe of Sony and Manning. He wants to stop this business of re-writing or falsifying blurbs for film ads.
Worse, Sony Pictures put a hit out on Manning, right after they murdered the fake critic.
“It was a case of incredibly bad judgment,” Sony spokeswoman Susan Tick said. “We were clearly distressed when we realized this had happened. The practice ended immediately. We’re taking all the steps necessary to determine who’s been responsible and will act appropriately.”
That was actually Ms. Tick’s quote. We didn’t make it up.
How quickly Hollywood and government turns to spit on genius.
How obvious that his fellow critics are so jealous of David Manning and his refined cinema tastes.
“The Animal,” stars another genius, Rob Schneider, former headliner of perhaps the funniest and greatest comedy ever on television— “Saturday Night Live.” In the title roll of this film, co-writer Schneider gets in a terrible car accident and has most of his internal organs replaced with animal parts. Hence, we have the twisting pathos of thespian Schneider trying to get along in a human world while besting his baser instincts.
Yes. There are those who will tell you, “Avoid this movie at all costs.”
Of course, there are those intellectual elite who will point to the stolen jokes, endless flatulence, bathroom humor, bestiality and an obvious Xeroxing of an Adam Sandler flick.
People.
In Hollywood, it’s not copying. It’s homage.
While the alleged Manning calls it, “Another Winner!” the Hollywood Reporter’s critic, David Hunter described “The Animal” as “A dive-bombing furball of a comedy.”
What does Hunter know? Not a single exclamation point in his prose, which, I’d like to point out, goes on and on and on for about 400 words.
“Columbia hopes to lure a few unsuspecting, undemanding 14-year-old victims into the theatre before the word gets around that the only animal Schneider effectively impersonates is a turkey,” noted so-called respected critic, Michael Medved.
Is there no charity in Medved’s heart? Can’t turkeys be funny? And, while Medved is quick to criticize, where are the exclamation marks in his review?
The nation’s other critics had their own blurbs on “The Animal” —
“Lame.”
“ Gross-out yucks.”
“It’s diseased.”
“ Minus-three stars.”
“Beneath The Planet of Blair Witch IV.”
To muddy the argument with such facts that David Manning is not a real person and is just the pseudonym for some sniggering Starbucks computer geek squirrelly acned intern with a 40-pound Adam’s apple in Sony publicity does disservice to legitimate art criticism everywhere. It is nothing short of a hate crime.
It is a sad day in Hollywood, a Mecca noted for its taste and ethics. We have lost a giant of a film reviewer in David Manning, and can only hope that some day, he shall be reincarnated, rising from his own ashes to show up in some pristine, out-of-the-way Montana monthly where his trenchant and refreshingly brief observations on movies— The American Art— can be shouted across movie ads around the world.
I hope I speak for the entire entertainment industry that we can hardly wait for Mr. Manning, or some industry flak like him, to review “Eyes Wide Shut, Part II.”
I’m thinking one word from Manning over those tens of thousands of movie ads: “OSCAR!”
God bless you, David Manning, for your courage...
John Boston’s Mr. Santa Clarita Valley column appears Wednesday through Saturday. To reach Boston, dial 259-1234 , ext. 242.
