“In the first place, God made idiots. That was for practice. Then He made school boards.”
— Mark Twain
A half-continent away, in the Gerald Ford state of Michigan, an honor student was recently expelled for bringing a knife to his junior prom.
Now at first glance, visions of “West Side Story” race to mind and being kicked out of school seems a rather reasonable and fitting punishment. But, as we start to peel back the paperwork and look at the facts, it is yet another case of a brainless cheese weenie school administration run amuck.
Here’s the skinny.
Jeremy Hix, 16, and his mom, were rather proud of their Scot heritage. For two years, his mother had been working on knitting an authentic highlander kilt, feathered cap and family colors tartan for his prom. Part of the straight A-student ’s costume included an authentic Scottish knife, displayed in a sheath.
Hix, who also plays the bagpipes, was spotted by a dance chaperone, who immediately overreacted by kicking the young boy out of the party. The school later added expulsion to the honor student.
I suppose the sin for Hix and his parents was not to fully measure the Salem Witch Hunt mentality of his high school and its district. Fools they were, they thought formal Scottish attire—including a knife—would be appropriate dress for a prom and something master Hix and his date would never forget.
They were right, albeit darkly.
What I cannot understand is the high-strung Barney Fife overreaction of the chaperone, the school and the district. Hix was not president of the Holt, Michigan chapter of the Crips. He erred in choice of fashion. The arresting teacher had an opportunity to approach young Hix and offer a calming smile and level-headed solution.
“Hey. That is one grand outfit you’re wearing. But you being an A-student , you might appreciate our problem of bringing a knife— even a ceremonial one— to a dance filled with teen-agers . How about we quietly just borrow that and return it to your folks on Monday morning?”
To silly me, that seems a reasonable start.
The kid, who was causing no trouble, gets to dance with his girl, get a non-police line-up prom picture taken and act goofy with his fellow youthful classmates.
But no.
That would make sense, wouldn’t it?
Instead, the Holt Unified School District adds insult to stupidity and follows up by expelling the kid.
Did I mention he was an honor student?
Under intense media coverage, the Board of Trustees harumphed and sucked in air, postured and acted like some gout-ridden 14th century college of cardinals. They pontificated and declared victory by offering a compromise— they’d only suspend Hix for just a semester.
In that semester, the junior would be able to take some college-level courses at the local J.C. He’d still be able to attend school events— social and sporting. And the expulsion would later be purged from his permanent record.
Well. How magnanimous of the good stewards of H.H.S.
“We’re glad that it’s over and the resolution is fair and reasonable,” said school board president John Malatinsky.
Having mastered Animal Farmspeak, I am confident Mr. Maltinsky has a larger career in elected service ahead of him.
To be sure, there are those teachers and administrators across the country who not only go the extra mile for their charges, they will run a marathon.
Daily.
But also every day, alleged grown-ups in positions of authority end up making themselves, their schools, their school districts and adults everywhere look mean, unfair and foolish.
We had a case several years back where a local administrator suspended a male first grader because he was pestering girls and lifting up their dresses. This member of the upper echelon of education wrote on the boy’s permanent record that he was a sex offender. On his permanent record— a sex offender. The kid was six years old.
We have reports of school districts adopting zero tolerance policies where they expel students for having fingernail files or two aspirin in their lunch pails.
I think in the Holt, Michigan case, the wrong person was kicked off campus for a semester. It should have been the arresting teacher, the principal, the local school board and any other large bodied dolts and mooncalves passing themselves off as educators.
John Boston’s Mr. Santa Clarita Valley column appears Wednesday through Saturday. To reach Boston, dial 259-1234 , ext. 242.
