Now, with the holidays done, we can part the fog and smoke and dust of all the noise, nonsense and outright lies that have come forth from the vicinity of City Hall since Dec. 14, and get a few facts straight.
Back on Dec. 14, I reported a story in this newspaper that revealed that the City Council, on Sept. 7, at a closed session meeting, authorized City Attorney Carl Newton to supply counseling and legal documents to attorney Jennifer Kilpatrick, who is representing Joan Dunn, Jackie Bettencourt, Lynne Plambeck and Councilwoman Jill Klajic in a private lawsuit against the Castaic Lake Water Agency.
The fur’s been flying ever since. At the Dec. 14 City Council meeting, Newton formally requested that the council waive attorney-client privilege so he could publicly address “the inaccurate and incorrect” items in the story. Councilwoman Klajic loudly and publicly declared, “Chris Dickerson is a liar. He tricked us.” And I have to figure it’s supporters of Klajic and Plambeck who’ve been howling at my door. Via unsigned e-mails , snail mails, and “Tell It’s,” there’ve been a variety of flaming arrows fired in my direction. One anonymous— but industrious— wag even went so far as to dig up an article about me that appeared in the Baltimore Sun in 1984 (it concerned a play I’d written) and post it on “Tell It’s.”
I know Klajic and Plambeck, who’s vice president of SCOPE and an elected member of the Newhall County Water District, are hardly fans of this newspaper, or specifically of mine. Klajic more than once has deemed The Signal a “ pro-growth anti-community activist” publication, which seems to be a perspective shared by Plambeck.
My opinion— and this is strictly my opinion, based on my experiences with them— is that Klajic, Plambeck and Joan Dunn don’t like my reporting because I refuse to put their “spin” on my stories, and because I no longer chase the wild geese they habitually set loose regarding either the Castaic Lake Water Agency or The Newhall Land and Farming Co. When I first started working here, almost two years ago, I used to take such “news tips” seriously. I soon realized I was wasting a lot of time and energy on foolishness that had more to do with certain people’s fantasies and egos, and little to do with true news value.
But that’s just my opinion. Let’s get back to facts.
Fact: The City Council held a closed session meeting on Sept. 7. According to Newton, the meeting started out as a discussion as to whether the council would join Klajic et al in their lawsuit against CLWA. When the council decided not to do so, the members then voted 3-2 to authorize Newton to help Klajic’s attorney, Kilpatrick, with the lawsuit. Klajic, Jan Heidt and Mayor Jo Anne Darcy voted in favor of the action. Council members Frank Ferry and Laurene Weste dissented, questioning the legality of the closed session, the vote and Klajic being allowed to vote on the issue.
Fact: Newton, according to both him and Kilpatrick, had already been having conversations regarding the lawsuit for at least a month prior to the Sept. 7 meeting.
Fact: Two legal experts said that the Sept. 7 meeting was outside the legal parameters of the Brown Act, which governs closed sessions. When the council decided not to be a party to Klajic’s lawsuit, the meeting should have been adjourned and reconvened publicly. And, legally, Klajic should not have been allowed to vote on an action from which she would personally benefit.
Fact: I’d heard rumors about this closed session meeting, but no one on the council would talk about it. Weste, Ferry and Darcy all said they’d been told by Newton that it was illegal for council members to discuss what goes on in closed session (it isn’t, and Newton has since denied he said this). The Klajic/Plambeck/Dunn/Bettencourt lawsuit was defeated on Sept. 2 and again on Sept. 22. When the plaintiffs filed a notice to appeal, I called Plambeck and Klajic, on Dec. 8, for a reaction. Plambeck said Newton had not participated in the lawsuit; she also said she didn’t have Kilpatrick’s phone number with her at work. Klajic said Newton “helped us a little at the beginning” of the lawsuit. Kilpatrick claimed she didn’t know Newton had been authorized by the council to help. Newton said he did help, but described his participation as “minimal.”
Fact: The same day as my phone call to Plambeck, she called Kilpatrick, and told Kilpatrick to ring Newton and warn him that I’d be calling “to try to link him to the case,” according to both Newton and Kilpatrick. Plambeck refused to comment on her call to her attorney.
Fact: On Dec. 13, as I was writing the story, a member of the City Council (not Klajic) called and asked that the story be held until after the Dec. 14, Tuesday night City Council meeting, so as not to affect the council’s vote for mayor that was scheduled that night. Signal Managing Editor Tim Whyte and publisher Will Fleet politely declined the request.
I interviewed Newton following the Dec. 14 vote, in which he was allowed to waive attorney-client privilege. He did not point out one “inaccurate or incorrect” fact in the original story, he only said he disagrees with others’ interpretations of the limitations of the Brown Act.
As for Klajic calling me a liar, she made the same accusation in a recent “Tell It” post (she also claims not to have read the news stories). She, too, has so far failed to point to one fact I misreported— I guess she’d have to read the stories to know what’s she talking about.
But that’s seldom stopped Klajic or Plambeck or their anonymous supporters. They don’t let facts upset their fantasies, or get in the way of their ego-driven crusades.
And one last personal point: At least when I level an accusation, I get the facts straight first, and I’m not afraid to put my name to it.
Chris Dickerson is a Signal staff writer. His column appears Thursdays.
