If there’s one thing American Indians know about, it’s having to fight the same battle over and over again.
In the 1850s and ’60s, to cite just one example, an Oglala Sioux war chief, Red Cloud, wasn’t too happy with the devil white eyes for building a string of forts along the Powder River, after— of course— they’d promised they wouldn’t. Red Cloud and his warriors launched a series of raids on the military bases, routing the soldiers and burning the forts down as fast as the U.S. Army could put them back up.
After roughly a decade of this, the Army did something it’d never done before: It begged the Indians for a peace treaty. Red Cloud agreed to stop torching the forts if the Army agreed to stop building them, and if the government further agreed to keep white settlements out of the Black Hills, the Oglala Holy Land.
That deal lasted until some enterprising souls discovered gold, and the Sioux watched as hordes of illegal immigrants (though the Sioux didn’t call them that) stormed the region. The U.S. government supported the settlers— of course. The Army sent Gen. George Armstrong Custer and his Seventh Cavalry to chase down and destroy the Indians. We all know how well that turned out, though the Sioux and Cheyenne weren’t allowed to remain victorious.
It’s one of the oldest stories in American history: Indians win, either in battle or negotiations, but they don’t get to keep the prize long. The Sioux, the Apache, the Navajo, the Nez Perce, the Comanche, my mother’s people the Cherokees, along with the Choctaws, Chickasaws, Delaware— those who are left from these and 500 other nations— all have similar tales.
But it didn’t all happen a century ago, or stop happening when the frontier closed; it isn’t ancient history; this fine American tradition remains with us to this very day.
Case in point: Proposition 1A, which addresses the issue of gambling on California’s Indian reservations. If it sounds familiar— like didn’t we settle this back in 1998— well, yes, the voters did. Prop. 5, as the measure was known, which was meant to secure the right of the state’s Indians to have gambling on their own federally mandated property, passed overwhelmingly, despite a multi-million-dollar ad campaign by Las Vegas casino interests to defeat the measure.
But the anti-Prop . 5 forces didn’t let a little thing like an election stop them. The California Supreme Court last summer told the Indians— and the rest of the voters— to go pound sand. The court found that the machines operated by the tribes were slot machines, and therefore not permissible under the state constitution, which bans slots.
Never mind that the tribes had machines that have no pull handles and do not dispense coins or currency; a slot machine, to the state Supreme Court, is anything the court decides is a slot machine, especially if certain powerful political and out-of-state business interests say it’s a slot machine.
So California’s Indians, who have used gambling revenues to offset meager government subsidies, to fight the malnutrition, disease, illiteracy, unemployment and drug abuse that have kept reservation Indians living in Third World squalor for generations, had to start all over again.
Prop. 1A comes up for a vote on Tuesday, but unlike Prop. 5, 1A is an amendment to the state constitution, backed by the state Legislature, the governor, the attorney general, law enforcement, labor and business leaders and Native American tribal leaders state-wide . It closes a few of Prop. 5’s loopholes, but, as usual, it also appears to give the white guys more of what they wanted in the first place, which they didn’t get with Prop. 5.
Prop. 1A, for instance, specifically dictates the number of casinos and machines a tribe may operate; it provides for stronger regulatory authority between the tribes and the state government; it increases revenue sharing with the state for regulatory costs; it mandates greater revenue sharing with non-gaming tribes and it has specific provisions for collective bargaining.
In short, where Prop. 5 basically reaffirmed Indians’ rights to do what they wanted as they wanted on their own land, Prop. 1A reminds Indians that they’re still a conquered people, with limited rights as dictated by the government.
Still, it’s better than nothing, which is pretty much what this country’s native people have had to learn to live with.
Chris Dickerson is a Signal staff writer. His column appears Thursdays.
