I’m not particularly happy to revisit this topic of uniforms in three of the local junior high schools. Not that I don’t think it’s an issue worth pursuing— and that issue, I’ll say again, is not whether uniforms in public schools are good or bad.
The issue— I’ll say it again, as I have a number of times in this space— is that the Hart School District told parents for several years that the wearing of uniforms at La Mesa, Placerita and Sierra Vista junior highs is “mandatory.” That is not accurate. The law in California, while somewhat confusingly worded, still makes it clear that a public school uniform policy is strictly voluntary. The Hart District neglected to tell parents that part, the rationale being (according to several school officials), if parents knew they didn’t have to buy uniforms for their junior high-age kids, they wouldn’t (yet the district continues to trumpet that uniforms have overwhelming parental support; no, I don’t get it, either).
The Signal first brought this issue to light in December ’98, when the American Civil Liberties Union threatened to sue the district for misleading parents into believing that uniforms are “required.” Another Signal reporter wrote about it again in September ’99, when a student at Placerita decided to opt out of the uniform policy and wear his own clothes (which any student is legally permitted to do).
Then I wrote about it some weeks ago, when a student at La Mesa chose to opt out. That’s when the storm really broke. Ever since, people have been publicly debating whether uniforms are good or bad.
Which— I’ll say it again— isn’t the point; nor is it the point that the ACLU got involved; nor is it the point whether I personally favor the uniform policy (it amazes me that anybody cares what I think, except those who misguidedly— and bizarrely— choose to believe that I reported the story because I have some personal axe to grind; I don’t; my son is high school-age , didn’t go to junior high here, and I have no personal opinions on whether children I don’t know wear uniforms).
The school district, however, continues to hammer the point that uniforms are good, and those who choose to opt out are somehow bad, or at least misguided. Uniforms contribute to school safety, the district contends (without, by the way, presenting one whit of evidence to back this up). It also contends uniforms contribute to a school’s learning atmosphere.
The district recently sent to parents a message entitled “Personal Freedom and the Common Good,” which ate up 12 paragraphs repeatedly making those two points, while soft-shooing around the issue of the district’s deception. The district also included a letter from a La Mesa parent extolling the virtue of uniforms.
All this is pretty hard-core lobbying, and it leaves one wondering why the district is so desperate to maintain its uniform policy. The safety argument is highly suspect, as is the supposedly improved academic atmosphere.
I don’t know the answer to that. I do know this much: There are, according to the district’s figures, 1,355 students enrolled at La Mesa, 1,335 at Placerita, 1,057 at Sierra Vista. Kelley Springs, the manager of the school uniform store (the only place where parents can purchase official school clothing), said she estimates parents spend approximately $250 per student per year for uniforms.
Let’s do the math: The combined number of kids at the three junior highs with a uniform policy is 3,747. At $250 each, that comes out to $936,750 per year— not bad for a little school uniform store.
Now, taking into account that, on average, about half of that money should go for inventory, rent, insurance, employee salaries, all the expenses of running a small business where the major shopping period is only in August, that still works out to roughly half a million dollars a year— still not too shabby.
It’s one thing if parents choose to pay that, knowing it’s a choice. It’s another thing entirely if parents are— have been— deceived, and the district remains sheepish about taking responsibility. There are still questions unanswered about this uniform situation. Parents should be demanding those answers, and not allow themselves to be distracted by some samba and cha-cha about “uniforms, good-uniforms , bad.”
Because— I’ll say it again— that’s not the issue.
Chris Dickerson is a Signal staff writer. His column appears Thursdays.
