Somewhere a cog may have shifted in the universe.
We see these things happen from time to time. Nobody knows why.
Call it fate or kismet, or the will of Buddha or the finger of God, or just plain ol’ down-home luck. Or coincidence (which I don’t believe in). Call it whatever, but it happens: A tiny, middle-aged , black cleaning woman refuses to give up her seat on a bus to a white man; a shaggy-haired student stands up at a college rally and declares, “It is time to put our bodies on the machine and stop it”; a security guard, making his rounds at the Watergate office complex, notices a strip of tape masking a door’s lock. He calls the cops. And things change.
That may be the whole point of the travesty that has spun around little Elian Gonzalez the past five months. It may finally change the way we— and most importantly the courts and the judges in this country— look at the relationship between fathers and their children.
Many single fathers across America watched the Gonzalez story unfold with a catch in their throats and anger in their eyes. They’ve seen the transparent tricks played by that despicable pack of Gonzalez relatives in Miami, the parading of that child for the benefit of news cameras and the anti-Castro mobs, the reprehensible videotape wherein Elian“told” his father he didn’t want to go back to Cuba, the stalling by the courts, the sanctimonious double-speak about “what’s in the best interest of the child” (when that’s often the last thing considered).
Single fathers who have been mauled by the court system know this scenario all too well. Elian’s father, Juan Miguel, has only had to withstand accusations of being a pawn of Castro. He hasn’t been accused of adultery, wife-beating , alcoholism, drug addiction or child sexual abuse, charges any self-respecting attorney will recommend an estranged wife to bring, if she wants custody of the children.
And more often than not, judges listen seriously to such charges— lacking any proof whatsoever except the estranged wife’s testimony. After all, shouldn’t children be with their mother? No matter which parent is best qualified to look after a child?
In the Gonzalez case, it’s interesting that only “George” magazine, out of all the national media, decided to dispatch a reporter to Havana to get the details on how Elian and his mother wound up in a leaking boat off the coast of Florida. We’ve all just assumed, of course, that Juan Miguel’s ex-wife was attempting to secure a new life of freedom for herself and her child in this shining republic across the sea.
The details are not quite as clean and neat, nor as laudatory: Elian’s mother, according to the story in “George,” was the one who decided to end the marriage after falling in love with another man, a man quite unlike staid, dull, Juan Miguel; a dashing motorcycle riding desperado who, on several occasions, had run afoul of Cuban law. He’d been jailed repeatedly, and not for political reasons— the guy was just a simple small-time crook. They have such things, even in communist countries.
At any rate, apparently Elian’s mother’s boyfriend got tired of being thrown in the Havana slammer. He decided to take off for someplace where the authorities have more of a sense of humor about stuff like petty theft. He made a beeline for Florida, leaving girlfriend and little Elian behind.
According to Cuban sources, though, Elian’s mother grieved for this guy something fierce. After several months, boyfriend returned to Cuba, in a rubber dingy with an outboard motor, at night across the Florida Straits.
He was promptly arrested when he hit Cuba, for entering the country illegally. After he got out of jail, he persuaded Elian’s mother to join him and about a dozen others in what can only be considered a foolish and dangerous attempt to reach America.
And of course, Elian’s mother decided to spirit the boy away without telling Juan Miguel, who had remarried and was attempting to rebuild his life while remaining a viable presence in Elian’s.
We all know the rest, a sad footnote in this country’s history, which would never have dragged on so long if the surviving parent was Elian’s mother, rather than Juan Miguel.
But maybe— just maybe— the Gonzalez saga will make people look closer at the viability of fathers, instead of keeping them one-dimensional figures, only good for weekend visits and writing support checks, and as the punchline in TV sitcoms. If Juan Miguel and Elian Gonzalez can bring us that, then their time in our company has been well-spent .
Chris Dickerson is a Signal staff writer. His column appears Thursdays.
