It's a phrase I've come to know like an old pal: "You sure don't look it!" The remark usually comes from somebody I know well. I'd have to know them well before I'd discuss with them in any detail my ethnic heritage, which is Scottish and American Indian. I don't make a practice of wearing around a sign, reading, " Scottish-Cherokee (Tell Me If I Look It)."
What I "don't look like," according to some people, is the Cherokee part. Nobody's ever told me I don't look Scottish. Nobody knows what Scottish looks like. There's Sean Connery of course, who, in a recent "60 Minutes" profile was called "the world's most famous Scotsman," but Connery's played Arabs and Spaniards, too, so maybe most people think Scots really look like Spanish Arabs— I know, it's confusing.
The funny thing is, when I was a kid, I didn't think I "looked" Native American. I didn't see me as Indian mainly because I didn't see what I saw in movies and on television. Then one day I realized that, with the exception of Jay Silverheels (Tonto to Clayton Moore's Lone Ranger, for all you real young people out there), Indians were played by Rock Hudson, Jeff Chandler, Sal Mineo and Charles Bronson.
Burt Lancaster was an "Indian" a couple times. He portrayed Geronimo once— or was that Chuck Connors? — and I remember him as All-American Jim Thorpe. I also have a vague memory of Tony Curtis as Ira Hayes, the Native American Marine who took part in the flag-raising on Iwo Jima (it took me a long time to realize the real Ira Hayes wasn't from the Bronx).
Maybe that's why people don't think I "look" Indian. I look nothing like Burt Lancaster or Tony Curtis. Or Sal Mineo. The funny part was, when I was a kid, the two actors I knew to have Indian ancestry, Robert Mitchum (Blackfoot and Scots-Irish /Dutch) and James Garner (Irish/Cherokee) never played Indians, even though they did a lot of Westerns— I know, this gets real confusing.
People who thought about it at all assumed I was Greek, Italian or, most often, Jewish. So, when I thought about it at all, I just figured I looked like a Greek-Italian-Jewish-Spanish-Arab-Scotsman .
Years later, though, I was doing some historical research and came upon photos of Native Americans by Edwin S. Curtis, taken at the turn of the century, and the earlier paintings of such Indian statesman-warriors as Tecumseh, Red Shirt and John Ross. Ross, the Cherokee nation's greatest leader in the 19th Century, was red haired and blue-eyed and wore affected European suits; now he looked Scottish. His ancestry was mostly Scottish. He and I looked nothing alike— damn confusing.
But I found plenty of photos of people who looked like me, like my mother, my aunts and uncles and cousins on my mother's side. The realization was that American Indians came in a vast array of facial characteristics and skin tones; hardly surprising when there's been 400 years of inter-marriage with the French, Spanish, Mexicans, Dutch, English, Scots, Irish, Germans and African-Americans . A few of my Indian brethren even looked a little like Burt Lancaster (none of them looked like Tony Curtis).
Still, I get this "you sure don't look it" stuff, I suppose because I don't stroll around in buckskins and feathers. But there's also something deeper at work here— a subtle racial context, which is saying, "You don't look like we think you should look, so we don't know whether to be prejudiced. This is confusing. We'll get back to you."
When I was working in Baltimore radio, at Shadow News & Traffic, we had a young station manager who had no more business being a boss than I would have being the ruler of Iran. The word "nigger" peppered his conversation, but nobody called him on it. He played golf with the upper management types. Most of us chose expediency— keeping our jobs— over moral courage.
One day, my then-girlfriend stopped by for lunch. After she left, the station manager said, "That's your girl friend? Boy, she doesn't look Jewish!" Meaning, I snapped, she doesn't have a hooked nose, horns and a tail? I think I used the word "idiot," too. I didn't work there much longer.
Looks, it's said, can be deceiving. To know the heart, the soul, to say nothing of the ethnic heritage, sometimes you can't tell by looking; and sometimes you have to look real deep.
Chris Dickerson covers politics for The Signal.
