This is what’s called “preaching to the choir.”
Because if you’re reading this, it means you read this newspaper. I know, that may sound like a “duh!” But if you’re reading this, and therefore this newspaper, this column is not directed at you. This column is directed at those who do not
read this newspaper, but who choose to whistle up a firestorm of complaints over its contents anyway.
I agree, that seems idiotic. How can anybody complain about a newspaper they don’t even read? Trust me, it happens all the time.
Years ago, back east, I had a guy call me up and launch a series of invectives over a story I’d written on his organization; this was not, I hasten to add, a head-busting investigative examination of embezzlement or fraud or abuse of power. It was a story outlining how this particular group had given thousands to local charities. It showed them to be good people. It was what we call basically a “puff piece,” having little “hard” news edge. Newspapers run such stories for two reasons: Organizations which do good, constructive works for the community deserve to be recognized, and newspapers can point to stories like that when we get accused of running nothing but bad news (usually by people who don’t read the newspaper).
So this was a “nice story” about this guy’s group and its humane activities. But he wasn’t happy. The story, he complained loudly, didn’t give his organization enough credit, or list all the charities they support.
“Sir,” said I politely, which was far from easy through gritted teeth, “When you read the story, did you count the number of charities I listed?” I’d charted something like 10 out of maybe 18.
Now here came the fun part. “Well,” he said, a little more quietly. “I haven’t read the story.”
“You,” I said, “haven’t WHAT?”
No, he admitted. Someone in his group had called him up and told him about it. Then, I said, “Why don’t you call me back when you’ve actually read the story?”
That was not an isolated case when I worked back east, and it’s not isolated to the East. By no means.
Let’s take, for instance, the Transit Mixed situation. Transit Mixed is the subsidiary of a Houston-based company which is seeking county approval to surface mine 80-some million tons of sand and gravel from a site in Canyon Country. The city of Santa Clarita, and the residents near the location on Soledad Canyon Road, are understandably concerned about this idea, and the impact it could have on air quality and water resources.
I understand their concerns. In fact, when I was first tipped off on this story, I jumped all over it. The Signal broke the story— nobody else reported it for three days— and we continued to run every piece of information we could find, covering hearings in front of the county Regional Planning Commission, City Council meetings, and neighborhood gatherings. All those stories— something like a dozen, give or take, so far— ran on the front page.
Yet I continued to get irate phone calls and e-mails from area residents, wanting to know why The Signal wasn’t covering the Transit Mixed story. Are you, I always asked, reading the newspaper? Well, one gentleman confessed, “I don’t see the paper every day.” Another woman said she “just started subscribing.”
Then there are certain community activists, folks who stand up at Santa Clarita City Council meetings and exercise their constitutional right to sneer at the city government for three minutes. Much of the time, these are relatively well-informed individuals whose comments are well-founded .
Ah, but there are exceptions. Most recently, there was a lady— she addresses the council regularly, and makes it clear she doesn’t like these people— who took the council to task for their “secret” deliberations on building a portion of Golden Valley Road across a strip of the chemically contaminated Porta Bella site. Now, I recognize that this woman is a great believer in conspiracies (she probably thinks Mayor Jo Anne Darcy was on the grassy knoll in Dallas on Nov. 22, 1963), but the City Council has a hard time keeping this topic secret; it’s been dealt with with on the front page, the editorial page and the Tell It’s page of this paper for months.
The old saying goes, if you don’t vote, you forfeit your right to complain. The same should be true of reading the newspaper. But then, the people who do the loudest complaining won’t get that, because they won’t have read it here. Maybe you’ll have to tell them.
Chris Dickerson is The Signal’s city editor. His column appears Wednesdays. Leon Worden’s column will appear on Fridays for the next two weeks, then will move to Fridays starting Aug. 6.
