Far be it from me to rain on anybody’s Fourth of July parade. Now that all the celebrating has come and gone, though, and seeing as how it was the last July 4th before the millennium, I’m going to demonstrate yet again that I have more guts than brains and make this point: There’s some of us who don’t get all that rah-rah over so-called Independence Day celebrations. As a quarter-Cherokee , and a student of history, I’ve always had a tough time embracing some of our accepted American rituals
and icons.
There’s Andrew Jackson, for one; “Old Hickory,” to most Americans, the hero of the Battle of New Orleans.
To the Indians, he was “Sharp Knife,” because he and his troops killed so many Cherokee, Chocktaw, Chickasaw, Creeks and Seminoles. When Sharp Knife became president of the United States in 1829, one of his first actions was the wholesale removal of these five nations to lands west of the Mississippi (despite the fact the Supreme Court ruled the action illegal; Jackson merely ignored it). The U.S. Army was ordered to round up and force-march several thousand Cherokees to the new “permanent Indian frontier.” On the long winter trek, one out of four Cherokees died from cold, hunger or disease.
So I’m not a big fan of Andy Jackson. Every time I go to the ATM and make a withdrawal, I feel like a descendant of Holocaust survivors carrying around a picture of Heinrich Himmler in my wallet.
Then there’s Mount Rushmore, with its granite faces of the Father Of Our Country, the author of the Declaration of Independence, the Great Emancipator, and that mighty trust-buster , the hero of San Juan Hill.
But there’s some of us who remember that Washington and Jefferson were slave owners, and Washington first became famous as a “mighty Indian fighter.” True, Lincoln freed the slaves, but only those in the states “currently in rebellion against the Government of the United States.” He also said if he could preserve the Union by freeing all slaves, he would; and if he could preserve it by freeing none, he’d do that, too.
In 1862, Lincoln was faced with a decision as to whether 303 Santee Sioux should be executed after a military tribunal in Minnesota found them guilty of murder. The trial was illegal: The post commanding officer, a man named Sibley, had decided the Indians had no legal rights, and were therefore not entitled to defense counsel.
Lincoln ignored this point, along with the fact that the defendants had engaged in a series of raids only because their families were starving, having been denied government food supplies they were entitled by treaty.
After reviewing the trial transcripts, Lincoln ordered that 39 of the 303 be executed. All well and good, except that the evidence against the Santee was shaky at best. It’s entirely possible that none of them killed anyone. They were hanged, in the biggest mass execution in our history. Lincoln, in the midst of a civil war, didn’t need rioting white settlers and an Indian war up in Minnesota, so he sacrificed those men.
Those are just a few examples, but hundreds are on the books, from the virtual slave labor of Chinese immigrants building the western railroad lines for a dollar a day, to the illegal deportation of American citizens from California during World War II, at the loss of their homes and businesses, for no other crime than that their parents or grandparents had been born in Japan.
That’s part of our past, and it’s a past that still rankles some, primarily because mainstream America doesn’t want to hear about it or acknowledge it. It’s pretty to pretend that we’ve never engaged in monstrous practices as a matter of national policy. ’Fraid not.
But one of America’s greatest virtues is its ability to change, to learn and to grow. As we face a new century, another hundred years’ worth of Fourth of Julys, we again have the opportunity to reinvent ourselves. We might think about putting up a statue or two to the likes of Martin Luther King Jr. or Caesar Chavez. As I recall, these two never killed anybody; they never owned another human being, either. We might even consider putting them on our money.
But the real change happens in our hearts. As the new century dawns, we could recognize that the beauty of America lies in its diversity, in the harmony of voices— Mexican, Chinese, Japanese, Vietnamese, African, ancient Cherokee— which combine to sing its song. We are a multi-ethnic culture, and that is our strength. America is far more colors than just red, white and blue.
Chris Dickerson is The Signal’s city editor. His column appears Wednesdays.
