I'm sorry.
I've felt compelled to do this every few years, more frequently in the last decade or so: To stand up and publicly apologize for my profession. Especially after this past summer. American journalism in the waning days of the 20th Century is in sad, sad shape, and the reporting of "Starrgate" these last months has dragged the entire industry, and our society, to one of the lowest points I've seen during 25 years as a reporter.
Back east, I taught journalism for awhile — the radio and television variety — at a fine trade school in Baltimore called the Broadcasting Institute of Maryland. I'd start the first class each semester with a little magical incantation.
"OK," I'd tell my college-age students. "Here it comes. Illy-meany-chilli-beany, the spirits are about to speak, poof! You're all reporters now. OK? Now, as reporters, I have a question for you. What's the news?"
The kids would look blankly at me, then at each other, then back at me. They thought I was nuts. It's the first class, for crying out loud, and here's this big bullet-headed teacher demanding to know, "What's the news?" Isn't he supposed to teach us what constitutes the news?
But there are always some brave souls in any classroom who are not afraid to look foolish. A few hands would slowly rise. "The news is ... information people need."
No.
"The news is, uh, facts."
No. Facts should be a component of the news, like a cough is part of a cold, but facts aren't the news. C'mon gang, you're reporters now. What's the news?
There'd be a few more admirable attempts to define the news, citing everything from the Constitution to, "It's what people want to know." All inaccurate, as was to be expected.
Finally I'd say, "OK, here's your answer. Remember, we're all reporters in here. And as reporters, the news is ... what we say it is. And that's all it is."
Because ultimately, as I've learned over the years, that's what the news is. What we in the business say is news, is news. Forget the fairy tales about objectivity. There's no such thing, never will be, so long as people select the information, and it's not done by machines which simply spit out data. People are not objective. We decide, based on what we journalists find to be important or interesting, which stories to put in this newspaper, and where to run them. There's nothing objective about that. That's the way the business works, whether the employer is a local daily newspaper or a major television network.
Back in 1979, ABC decided to air special reports every night at midnight on the Iran-Hostage situation. This went on for over a year, until the American hostages were freed, the day of Ronald Reagan's inauguration. That program alone didn't defeat Jimmy Carter. Double-digit inflation, rampant unemployment, out-of-control gasoline prices and Carter's own general ineptitude greatly contributed. Still, U.S. presidents who were far greater disasters than Jimmy Carter have ridden on to a second term. But the program — we now call it "Nightline" — kept the hostage issue burning bright, night after night after night.
We've had a similar situation since January with the Clinton-Lewinsky-Starr story. Is it an important story? In the grand history of the this republic, probably not, unless Clinton does something even more stupid and resigns over it. The press, though, led by network television news, which leads the metropolitan daily newspapers, which lead the rest of us, thinks it's important. Therefore, it is. Therefore we hear about little else. The news is what they say it is.
If the decision were made that the number of American families living at or below the poverty level, or the number of children who go without school lunches, or health insurance, or the names and faces and reasons for the homeless, that those things were news of equal importance, what a different world this might be.
* * *
Chris Dickerson covers the city beat for The Signal.
