The American Bar Association recently sent out a letter containing the thoughts of ABA president Bill Paul on the subject of “juvenile justice.” According to the ABA cover letter, in response to the recent various incidents of violent youth crime, “pressure in Congress to pass a juvenile justice bill this year is growing.” Paul thought it might be useful to get his views on various proposals out to the public.
Among other things, Paul urges that “children must be kept in facilities separate from adult prisoners,” that “children must have access to effective and affordable legal counsel,” and that Congress should “help states raise funds” for community-based programs aimed at reducing juvenile crime.
Paul’s first two points can hardly be argued with. On that last point, Paul’s correct: Community programs are helpful. But we might start with something a bit more basic. When it comes to dealing with kids, attitude is everything, and right now our attitude is lousy.
Just kicking back on vacation some weeks ago, I decided to click on daytime TV, to see if it was as bad as rumors claim it is. It was worse. And I don’t mean the silly though harmless nonsense on soap operas, or even Jerry Springer’s bizarre parade of hopeless malcontents. At least Springer picks on grown-ups .
Over on Maury Povich’s circus, he was doing a program with a theme something like, “My teen dresses sexy and it’s driving me crazy.” The poor hapless parents told alternately tearful and disgusted stories about the outrageous clothes their teen-agers wear. Then the kids were brought on, in their skimpy outfits, to a pulsating disco beat and the screaming boos of the audience.
It was the boos that got me. I’d seen similar moments on Sally Jesse Raphael and Jenny Jones, and would come across it again on Ricki Lake. The hostility with which these children were met— and they were children, between 13 and 16 years old— swept off the TV screen like an acid wave.
The capper for the day was over on Judge Judy, where Ms. Hardcase from Noo Yawk was screeching at an 11-year-old for lying to her (yeah, an 11-year-old ).
It’s pretty interesting when our society has evolved to the point where we put emotional child abuse on television as a form of entertainment.
I guess this shouldn’t be surprising. A year or so ago, I covered a town hall-type meeting, sponsored by the city, the local schools and law enforcement, aimed at drug awareness on the part of parents. A panel discussion was held, with education, law enforcement and counseling professionals as speakers. The motivation behind the gathering was positive; the advice being dispensed was, to me, highly suspect.
“Search your kid’s room,” the parents were told by more than one professional participant. “ Teen-agers have no rights of privacy, they have no rights at all. Question them, quiz them, check out their friends, watch them closely, and at the first sign of trouble, land on them.”
Not once was any advice offered like, “Show your kids you love them, and you’ll trust them until they give you a reason not to. Tell them honestly about the dumb and potentially dangerous things you did at their age. Treat them with respect and let them know you expect the same in return. Make them feel that losing your respect and trust is the worst thing that could ever happen to them.”
I’m not sure how we got to this point. Maybe my generation, those of us who grew up in the ’60s, who are now the parents of these kids, resent the hell out of them for reminding us that we’re not 25 anymore. Maybe the only example we have is our parents, who had their own, and far different reasons, for resenting us.
But at least our parents were honest. In the ’60s and early ’70s, we launched a frontal assault on the values that sustained them through the Depression and World War II, and maybe they suspected that our loudly professed “convictions” were wafer thin; time has certainly proved them right.
And one of the ways we gave up, gave out, gave in is in our mass treatment of our kids today. We swore we’d be better than our parents, more compassionate, more understanding, more honest. For the most part, we haven’t been any of those things. Then we wonder why they’re angry and suspicious and resentful. Maybe they’re just reflecting the example they’ve had set for them.
Chris Dickerson is a Signal staff writer. His column appears Thursdays.
