My old Cherokee cousin Will Rogers used to say, “Some folks’re always talkin’ about their ancestors, and they try’n impress you by sayin’ things like, ‘My family can trace its roots in this country back to the Mayflower.’ I tell ’em my people met the boat.”
Actually, Will, one of the most popular newspaper columnists of the century and certainly one of the best-loved figures of the 1930s was a cousin of mine only in the “extended family” sense. He was from Oklahoma, which made him a Western Cherokee, while my relatives clung to the Ohio Valley Region, which made us Eastern Cherokee.
And, to be real accurate about this, the people who “met the boat” when the Mayflower grounded at Plymouth, Mass., in 1620 were members of the Wampanoag nation. They didn’t precisely “greet” the Pilgrims with flowers and champagne, either. These were not the first white people the Wampanoags had seen, and they’d heard of their cousins’ (in the extended family sense), the Powhatans’, encounters with the English settlers of Virginia in 1607, and before that the murderous methods of the Spanish who’d followed in the wake of Columbus almost two centuries before. So the Wampanoags were at first cautious and kept their distance.
But finally the tribal fathers, touched by the struggles of these new neighbors to survive in a strange land (the Wampanoags looked upon the Plymouth colonists as helpless children), appointed four ambassadors as missionaries: A Pemaquid called Samoset and three Wampanoags, Chief Massasoit, Squanto and Hobomah. All four spoke some English, which they’d learned from explorers who’d passed through the region over the years.
Squanto’s language skills had been particularly hard-earned . Years before, he’d been kidnapped by an English seaman and sold into slavery in Spain. But he’d managed to escape and make the long trek back home, and held no grudge against whites in general.
We know the next part of the story (fogged, tilted and chopped though it’s been, through centuries of telling and re-telling in history classes): The Indians shared corn from the tribal stores with the near-starving Pilgrims, they showed them where and how to catch fish, and saw them through that first brutal winter in the New World. When spring came, the Indians made the whites a gift of seed corn and taught them how to plant and cultivate it.
Which, so the legend goes, led to that first Thanksgiving. The colonists had learned their lessons well, and had enough food the following autumn to host a feast for themselves and their Indian benefactors. As it is not the Indian way to receive without giving something in return, the Wampanoags brought wild game to the banquet as well, and the devout Pilgrims gave thanks for their survival— and the overwhelming kindness and generosity of their Indian neighbors.
The last part of that sentence often gets left out of high school history lessons. So does the part about the colonists asking Samoset, in 1625, to give them 12,000 additional acres of Pemaquid land, to accommodate all the new settlers flooding in to what they now called “New England.” Samoset knew he could no more give away land than he could give away the clouds or the stars, because it all came from the Great Spirit and belonged to no man. But, out of a polite sense of humoring his white friends with their bizarre rituals, Samoset participated in a “land transfer” ceremony and made his mark on a paper for them. It was the first deed of Indian lands to English colonists in America.
When my son and I sit down to our dinner today, all these many Thanksgivings later, I’ll remind him of the broad scope of the Pilgrim-Indians story. He’s heard it before, of course, but mostly in his public school classes, which most often stress the Eurocentric point of view. We’ve gotten to know the Pilgrims well over the centuries; we can spot Pilgrims just by their style of dress. The Wampanoags remain shadowy figures. Most Americans can’t tell the difference between a Wampanoag, a Cherokee, a Sioux or any of the other approximately 3 million Indians who lived on this continent in the first 200 years of the European influx. It’s understandable, in a way: The Wampanoags no longer exist.
But for me, what I primarily want my son to be aware of is that there was a time when Americans could, in friendship and respect, sit down at the table together: Major differences in race, religion and culture mattered little at that first Thanksgiving. The colonists were joyful at having survived, and the Indians, like proud parents, took delight in the prospering of their new friends. It wouldn’t last, unfortunately, but maybe it’s something we can strive to re-invent in the Thanksgivings to come.
Chris Dickerson is a Signal staff writer. His column appears Thursdays.
