I've always had mixed feelings about one of the leading features of The Signal.
Before I started as chief operator of this newspaper, but after I had accepted the job, I read Tell it to The Signal every day and cringed.
As a publisher, I felt spine-tingling chills. Before I ever stepped foot in my office, I started practicing my disclaimer lines:
"Yes, Mr./Mrs. Mayor, I know that the Tell It in today's paper about you was unfair. The person's comments were certainly not reflective of what we think about you.
"Yes, Mr./Mrs. Mayor, I know that the person would have commented differently if he/she had to put his/her name on the Tell It just as we require on letters to the editor.
"No, Mr./Mrs. Mayor, I have no plans to eliminate Tell it to The Signal. It is one of the most popular items in the newspaper and very well-liked by most readers. Unfortunately, public figures who will be the target of the many strong, freewheeling comments in Tell It are not going to like it.
"And I don't blame you."
As a reader, I was entertained, but I still wanted to edit or kill several of the Tell Its each day.
Later, it turned out that one of my legacies here will be that we mitigated the impact of Tell it to The Signal.
First, we put Tim Whyte in the head editorial position and he took over the job of editing and killing several irresponsible Tell Its each day. We regularly eliminate phone and online Tell Its that criticize businesses because the anonymity of the feature allows another business, for example, to attack its competitor. We've certainly had thinly veiled attacks posted online that have obviously come from employees of other publications.
Next, we moved Tell It off of the editorial pages and put it here on Page 2. This maneuver produced several positive results. Foremost, it separated the more open, and sometimes a little wacky, commentary of Tell It from the serious editorial positions, guest columns and letters to the editor. Further, it gave Tell It a life of its own, making it virtually a section of the newspaper.
As a former editor, I'm still occasionally troubled by the anonymous nature of Tell It. If a contributor is going to be critical of someone or something, they should sign their name and stand behind their opinions, just as the rest of us do.
We addressed that issue by responding with editor's notes to the calls or posts that have particularly nasty or inaccurate or downright foolish content. The callers and posters know that even though they will not be identified, they will be "called" on absurdities.
However, Tell It has taught me a lesson over the years.
Anonymity, while problematic, has helped Tell it to The Signal make The Signal a better newspaper. A newspaper's job is to inform, entertain and provide a forum for the community to communicate with each other. There is no other single element of the newspaper that polishes the mirror of the community more than open discussion among the regular folks of that community.
As webmaster Paul Sisson said the other day, he likes the online Tell It because it generally focuses on the real issues of the Santa Clarita Valley. For example, Friday's posts on www.the-signal.com are about a traffic sign, the school district boundary line decisions, local gangs, bigotry in the SCV, storage of motor homes on local streets, traffic at Seco Canyon Road and Copperhill, Father Norm of Our Lady of Perpetual Help and the Valencia Freshman basketball team.
The nice thing is that as of 12:30 p.m. Friday, only a about three posts were about the tired impeachment drama.
The comments were mainly about local matters, what affects each of us every day.
These are the issues that make this a great community and what we believe make us a great community newspaper.
* * *
Will Fleet is publisher of The Signal. He can be reached at 805-259-1234 or at the e-mail address below.
