Lynne Plambeck, first vice president of Santa Clarita Organization for Planning and Environment was quoted recently:
“I sort of feel like sometimes it’s a situation where if you don’t build it, they won’t come,” Ms. Plambeck said, reversing the “Field of Dreams” formulation.
The writer continued:
The reality is not quite so simple, of course...
The quote came from an article about the Santa Clarita Valley, and more specifically the Newhall Ranch project, that appeared in the New York Times a couple weeks ago.
It was a tightly written piece that concisely captured the essence of the legal and emotional battles over the development of the area just west of the Interstate 5 freeway that cuts through the western portion of the verdant (sorry J.B.) Santa Clarita Valley.
Ironic, isn’t it, that even someone as removed from the situation as the New York Times can figure out that “The reality is not quite so simple, of course.”
I’ve always wondered why certain members of the SCOPE group have so much trouble figuring it out. A lot of us are sympathetic to legitimate environmental issues. I even consider myself a tree-hugger . I don’t care much one way or the other about planted landscape trees like the eucalyptus nuisances along McBean Parkway, but Heritage Oaks are important to, well, our heritage in California.
Plambeck and other no-growth advocates will use any tool at their disposal no matter how odd or insignificant. And lawyers for the county of Ventura, SCOPE and other groups have no trouble ignoring the facts when it comes to their current lawsuit against Newhall Land and Farming, the builder of Newhall Ranch.
I love the quotes from attorney John Buse who claimed in his opening statements Thursday, when he brought up the principal “endangered” species threatened in his opinion by Newhall Ranch: The Dreaded Unarmored Three-Spined Stickleback. It’s a fish, by the way, a very significant fish.
If you are fishing in the Santa Clara river and you catch the stickleback, throw it back.
Even more comical was the attorneys assertion that “The EIR (Environmental Impact Report on Newhall Ranch) fails to provide answers to questions on how the project will impact the stickleback fish and other wildlife.”
After seeing that statement, we can be certain of one thing: Hogwash is not an endangered species. The EIR is full of information about wildlife species, habitats and vegetation. The EIR is required to address those issues in voluminous detail. Good god, the EIR documents are over four feet tall. Thousands and thousands of pages.
If the Ventura County lawyers can’t come up something better than “the EIR failed to address wildlife issues,” they can close the books on this case now.
In their defense, the same attorneys did bring up the issue of water, which is obviously critical. There are varying opinions between the developers and the no-growthers over the availability of water. I generally disagree with the no-growthers ’ assessments, but at least water is a legitimate issue.
After all, we must have a place for all the sticklebacks (stickleback?) to swim.
The lawyers also mention traffic and air pollution, which are quite well addressed in the EIR. The relevance is also questionable because we are going to have the traffic and pollution issues no matter where the people live in Southern California.
The problem the no-growthers have is accepting that the people are going to be here regardless of whether we build Newhall Ranch.
Lynne, they are most certainly coming, whether we build it or not. We can build responsibly, recognizing that we basically have no choice, or we can spend our lives tilting at windmills. SCOPE and other groups seem to choose the latter.
The Los Angeles region, as the New York Times pointed out, is going to add 6 million more people in the next 25 years. Newhall Ranch won’t be a drop in the bucket to serve the needs of 6 million more residents.
Instead of suing an already-approved development it would be nice if SCOPE and like entities would spend more of their time on realistic matters of the environment, like how we can continue to improve the region’s air quality.
Another great cause would be population growth control and family planning.
If you really want to control growth, that’s at the heart of it.
Will Fleet is publisher of The Signal. He can be reached at 259-1234 , ext. 291, and his email address is [email protected] .
