“A great pleasure in life is doing what others say you can’t.”
—MY FORTUNE COOKIE ON
FRIDAY FROM PANDA EXPRESS
I hate fortune cookies that recite such ruminations instead of fortunes. I like fortune cookies that say things like, “You will be wealthy and happy beyond your wildest dreams,” or “You will win your next game by hitting a home run in the last inning.”
I want to feel fortunate when I read a fortune cookie. I do not want to feel philosophical.
This wasn’t a fortune cookie. It was a proverb cookie. Hate those.
Except this one, because I opened it just as I was reading about and thinking about young Ashleigh Collins and her parents: “A great pleasure in life is doing what others say you can’t.”
We all know when we’re young that Mom and Dad don’t know anything.
When my kids were little, it was a game sometimes to challenge them by saying, “You’re not going to make it.” My kids, especially the daughter, became more determined when you told her she couldn’t do something. Unfortunately, that has worked against me when I really want them not to do something, because they then questioned my credibility and whether I know what I’m talking about when I say, “You can’t (or shouldn’t) do that.”
Ah, the pitfalls and potholes of parenting.
Julie and Jeff Collins may have one foot in a parenting pothole with their little Ashleigh right now.
Ashleigh Collins is the 12-year-old student who has chosen to buck the system by refusing to abide by the uniform policy at La Mesa Junior High School.
“My parents were really supportive,” Ashleigh said in The Signal’s article on Friday.
The question is “supportive of what?”
One one hand, Jeff and Julie are encouraging Ashleigh’s individual thinking, assuming that not wearing the uniform clothing is all Ashleigh’s idea. They are allowing her to make her own decisions, which can be very healthy for kids, especially adolescents who are just beginning to find their way.
On the other hand, they’re teaching her disrespect for authority and rules. In today’s world, kids don’t need much help with the latter lesson.
In any civilized society there are boundaries. Which ones should Ashleigh stay within and which ones can she step over? Which boundary will she cross next, fully expecting “support” from her parents?
What will Jeff and Julie tell Ashleigh when she wants bright blue hair, tattoos all over her body, and maybe a tongue ring or two? How about when Ashleigh decides that auto speeding laws are as useless as the uniform policy? How about drugs?
Their answer is undoubtedly that “those things are different,” or “they are extreme examples.” Are they? Spent any time at the mall lately?
Well, maybe all of this is none of our business. Except that Ashleigh and her parents have decided to make it a public matter. The Collinses came to the newspaper with their story, at least in part because they feel Ashleigh is being teased and perhaps ostracized by other students, and the school isn’t doing enough to prevent it.
I remember junior high school. I was tough enough without asking for trouble, but somehow we all ask for it at one time or another. I remember being an unrepentent candy-eater in class. Alas, even after my best buddy Curt Beeson got swatted for eating candy in history class, I kept doing it. Sure enough, Mr. Miller came up to my desk in the middle of a lecture, bent down and whispered in my ear, “I womped Beeson and now I’m gonna have to womp you!”
After the eye-watering pounding Mr. Miller gave me in the Principal’s office, I relented, I repented, and I learned a lesson about following rules - even the rules that I thought were silly or I didn’t necessarily agree with.
The William S. Hart High School District and the administration at the school have indicated that they believe Ashleigh is going out of her way to draw attention to herself. If this is true, and I realize that there are varying interpretations of the truth in this case, Ashleigh may indeed be “asking for it.”
“We’ve had students ‘opt out’’ for various reasons and there were no problems,” said Superintendent Bob Lee. “Ashleigh has been very different in her appearance.”
Is Ashleigh right about dressing any way she pleases? Is she a martyr or a troublemaker? Is she right or wrong. However you feel, the fact is that she and her parents are forcing the issue.
In her own way, like it or not, Ashleigh is provoking her classmates.
That doesn’t make it right to haze, tease, or to use today’s politically correct legal jargon “harass” Ashleigh. But when 99 percent of the kids are following the rules, and one chooses to follow her own rules, many kids are going to resent it. Junior high school kids are particularly good at expressing such resentment in the form of teasing. It can be insensitive at best and cruel at worst.
Looking at it from the angle of the vast majority of students who have followed the uniform policy, some of them probably think something like: “Ashleigh thinks she’s too good to dress like the rest of us.”
There’s a fine line between courage and arrogance.
Will Fleet is publisher of The Signal. He can be reached at 259-1234 , ext. 291, and his email address is [email protected] .
