City Manager George Caravalho, when apprised that The Signal had potentially controversial information on the city’s recycling compliance, which is mandated by the state of California, quickly prepared and distributed an information package for the City Council on Friday.
This package was apparently designed to show that the city’s potential non-compliance with Assembly Bill 939, the California Integrated Waste Management Act was no big deal.
And maybe it isn’t.
What bothers everyone is that we don’t know. Staff doesn’t seem to know what the problem is. The City Council just heard of the problem.
Even though the story reported that the waste diversion from landfills went from 51 percent in 1998 to only 25 percent in 1999, it also pointed out that AB 939 requires only 25 percent for those years, but 50 percent in 2000. The 2000 figures are not yet available.
Karl McCarthy, the local manager for Waste Management, which picks up most of the city’s trash, said the figures are simply wrong.
“Obviously waste has been allocated to the city that was never generated in the city,” McCarthy explained. “The city’s investigation will find where the discrepancies are.”
The timing couldn’t be worse for Waste Management, who may not deserve blame for the drop in waste diversion, especially if the figures are not accurate. Waste Management’s proposed contract to continue as the franchise trash hauler for most of the city is scheduled for discussion and a probable vote at Tuesday night’s City Council meeting.
The bigger problem for the city to deal with as it ponders the future of waste hauling is whether any recycling statistics can be believed.
A centerpiece of Waste Management’s proposal is the construction of a MRF (material recycling facility) to help substantially enhance recycling efforts in Santa Clarita.
If the city’s or the landfill’s measurements of waste diversion are dramatically inaccurate, then were those figures bad in 1998 too? What makes us think they will be accurate in the future? Whose responsibility is it to get these figures right? Who is accountable to whom?
Does the city verify that reported recycling figures are real? Who reports the numbers, the landfill operators? The trash haulers?
These are the kinds of questions that need to be answered thoroughly before moving forward on any recycling program or facility.
* * *
The response to our investigation of the city’s “waste diversion” situation was disappointing to say the least.
After reporters from The Signal had been working on a recycling story for a couple weeks, someone on the city staff apparently called another locally distributed newspaper to make sure they also had the story that we had been working on for some time.
Nothing illegal or particularly dastardly about a city staff member sharing our information with another publication.
But it’s bad form.
* * *
It was good to see that the Stevenson Ranch Town Council finally voted on Wednesday to have an election again.
While the town councils of Castaic and Stevenson Ranch are not actual governing bodies like the Santa Clarita City Council, their actions have real impact on what happens in their respective communities.
Further, these councils were formed at the request of Los Angeles County Supervisor Mike Antonovich’s office. That means that they are public structures and should be operated as democratically as possible.
Recent new town council members in Stevenson Ranch have been appointed by President Keith Pritsker rather than elected by the residents of Stevenson Ranch, because the scheduled November election was canceled.
Some of the issues yet to be resolved include who is going to pay for the election, and more interestingly, how much it will cost.
Castaic’s recent election cost $200. The Stevenson Ranch Town Council called off its November 2000 election, throwing around cost figures like $5,000. As Castaic proved, it should not cost that much to run an election that will be targeted to only about 3,000 households. No more than a few hundred votes will likely be cast.
A couple of us could count those votes in less than an hour.
Will Fleet is publisher of The Signal. He can be reached at 259-1234 , ext. 390, and his email address is [email protected] .
