Mount Shasta City
It’s an age-old argument: The public interest as told by government officials versus the public’s right to know.
Government officials, whether elected or paid staff members, commonly maintain that secrecy in certain negotiations is best for us all.
For example, if the city is negotiating the price on a piece of real estate, negotiations could be compromised if the seller of the property knows what the city is offering.
At times, perhaps the bureaucrats are right that confidentiality can be a valuable asset. The problem is when you give them an inch of secrecy, they take a mile.
Gov. Gray Davis has taken several miles in the case of his pursuit of power contracts. On behalf of California, Davis is attempting to purchase billions of dollars in electricity without providing any details of the negotiation to the public.
Here in the beautiful foothills of Mt. Shasta at the quarterly board meeting of the California Newspaper Publishers Association, the state’s power crisis was naturally one of the hot topics of discussion. Earlier in the week, the California First Amendment Coalition— which is sort of a sister organization to CNPA— released results of a poll of residents that overwhelmingly called for Davis to release details of the state’s energy deals.
CFAC’s poll indicates that 71 percent of Californians say they are getting too little information about the state’s response to the power crisis, and an incredible 86 percent say the details of the power purchasing contracts should be made public.
Kent Pollack, executive director of CFAC, said, “Californians reject government secrecy as a matter of law in the state’s open government act. The poll results are an overwhelming repudiation of state policy.”
Not including the utilities, Davis (34 percent), the state Legislature (31) and the usual whipping boy “news media” (16) were blamed for the lack of information in the crisis. However, when the utility companies were included as the choice of a culprit, 63 percent of Californians blamed the utilities, compared to only 23 percent for state officials and 7 percent for the news media.
Interestingly, the media doesn’t get as much blame as usual in this controversy, possibly because the public wants the media to have access to the information.
The key question about whether the details should be released was fairly and objectively posed in the following manner: “Officials say keeping the details private will help the state negotiate the lowest price on electricity for California consumers and that making details public would make electricity more expensive. Critics say the details should be made public because the public has the right to know the cost and provisions of the contract as a matter of public policy and because the public is paying the bills. In your opinion, should the state keep the details private or make the details public?”
Public beat private 86 percent to 11 percent, with 4 percent “not sure.”
A lot is at stake.
The governor undoubtedly believes in his heart that private negotiating is in the state’s best interest. Davis thinks we should trust his experience and professional judgment.
Santa Clarita city officials have often used the same logic for conducting public business in private: “We’re the professionals. We know best.” And that’s when government crosses the line.
The linchpin of American freedom is open government. It’s the difference between the USA and all of the failed communist countries and totalitarian dictatorships.
We have the right to know what government is doing with our tax dollars. We have the need to know if our form of representative government is to survive.
At any level of government, when a single person becomes more powerful than the electorate— and the people allow it to continue— American democracy fails.
Will Fleet is publisher of The Signal. His column appears Sundays, and he can be reached by calling 259-1234 , ext. 390. His e-mail address is [email protected]
