The signs of a showdown are everywhere.
The deadline for the city of Santa Clarita's sign ordinance is just 181 days away (Nov. 13), and there are hundreds of signs around town that are not in compliance.
Even with a very short turnaround time of just a few days, more than 100 surveys about the ordinance have been returned to The Signal. The results will be tallied by the Chamber of Commerce , but one thing's clear: It's a compelling issue to local businesses.
One of the responses was very blunt: "Taking down my signs will affect my business and hurt my family."
City staff and some members of the City Council will quickly reply, "It won't hurt their business. Better-looking signs will only help everyone."
Well, that's easy to say, but I'm not sure there's any proof to back up those claims. If you haven't worked for years to build a business and struggled every week to meet payroll, you have no idea how tough it can be to come up with money to build a new sign-and even more importantly-how difficult it might be to compensate for a reduction in exposure caused by smaller and shorter signage.
Is it right for a city to force a businessperson to spend thousands of dollars on a perfectly good sign because the Council thinks it's too big? Or in the wrong position? Or whatever.
One survey response said, "Signs installed prior to 1990 should not be affected by the new ordinance unless the business has changed."
These are some of the complicated issues that arise when you try to legislate free expression. In the purest form of common sense, if I have a piece of commercial property, I should be able to put a sign on it to advertise my business. A big sign. A small sign. Sign, sign, everywhere a sign.
It would be nice, I guess, if all of the commercial areas in town could look like Valencia, or would it?
Most folks want a "clean- looking" community. Problem is, who decides what is " clean-looking "?
Remember, this is the same city that approved the design of the Princess Cruises building. Does clean mean a sign of 47 colors?
One of the other issues irking some businesses is that the city spent $100,000 on a consultant just for the purpose of figuring out who is and who isn't in compliance. Some have suggested that the $100,000 could have gone a long way toward helping finance replacement signs for small businesses.
The staff members responsible for the sign ordinance are good people. I've met and talked with them several times on the matter. But they are not businesspeople.
They want to be sensitive to the needs of businesses, but aren't quite sure how to go about it. That's why we at the Chamber of Commerce decided to do some outreach to the business community to get more direct feedback. We felt that we could get better information by communicating businessperson-to-businessperson than the city could gather with the bureaucrat-to-businessperson approach.
The Council and staff have passively resisted suggestions to amend the ordinance to perhaps make it less restrictive or at least extend the deadline period.
Reality could set in on the deadline issue soon.
Regardless of whether the staff will eventually accept the dreaded "A" word (amendment), they might as well extend the deadline right now, because there is no chance that compliance will be achieved this year.
If every sign in Santa Clarita is in compliance by Nov. 13 with the city's ordinance as currently written, I will give Jan Heidt a non-stop piggyback ride from Lyon's Avenue to Creekside. Round trip. With a snack.
Will Fleet is publisher of The Signal. He can be reached at 259-1234 , ext. 291, and his email address is [email protected] .
