As the 1999 president of the Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce and someone who cares a lot about this community, I would hate to be the Grinch Who Stole the All America City Award.
So I’ve waited ’til today to comment on Santa Clarita’s participation in the National Civic League All America City program.
The bottom line is that the program, which may seem only positive on the surface, is one big misnomer and Santa Clarita doesn’t belong in it.
Still, this is a sticky wicket for critics, me included, because there are dozens of good citizens locally who have participated in the program and are in Louisville, Ky., right now trying to bring home the All America City designation. Some of them have worked hard and given much time and money.
And they’re having a lot of fun. It’s a great party by all accounts and for that, it’s hard to fault anyone for being a part of it.
The totals for this year are not yet in, but last year, ouch, we spent about $100,000 in private and public money on All America City. If the whole idea of being an “All America City” is to promote the community, imagine what we could do with a $100,000 marketing campaign.
Plus, unlike the All America City program, we could control the message and tell the whole truth.
Even though there are a number of local civic leaders who cringed at the city of Santa Clarita’s misleading application last year, most of them remained on the sidelines rather than appear negative to a project that is a pet of Mayor Jo Anne Darcy’s. If George Washington is the father of our country, Jo Anne Darcy is the mother of our city.
Still, even for Jo Anne, we can’t continue to stand by while Santa Clarita is portrayed once again as a struggling community that has “turned around” its gang problem.
The city made similar claims last year, quietly ruffling a number of local leaders who felt the portrayal was inaccurate. In fact, several members of the city staff (who shall remain nameless to my grave) disagree with the city’s approach and even its participation in the program. But the same strategy was adopted again this year, apparently because the National Civic League is looking for such “turnarounds” as criteria for selecting All America City winners.
To be fair, there are other low-profile elements of the application that are harmless and forthright. But they are low-profile .
When you look at the list of past California winners of the All America City Award, it begins to make sense, sort of.
Westminster is an All America City.
San Bernardino is an All America City.
Oakland is an All America City.
Fresno, as of Saturday, is an All America City.
This is the kind of company that we’ve worked so hard to join.
Nothing against these communities, but they cannot hold a candle to Santa Clarita in terms of safe streets, education, location and overall quality of life.
Fresno was recently chosen by a national magazine as the nation’s least desirable place to live. But the National Civic League named it an All America City, and somewhere, somehow, we came down with Fresno Envy.
Here is the opening text of our city’s application for the 2000 All America City Award:
“Drawn by a peaceful, promising and crime-free life, people flocked to Santa Clarita from the crowded Los Angeles basin. Many people flooded the area with the well-intentioned notion of leaving their problems behind. They came to start over... to find the community of their dreams. Unfortunately, what many hoped to leave behind— crime, congestion and a lack of local jobs— followed the massive influx of new residents...
“Gang membership skyrocketed from 150 gang members in 1991 to over 1,300 in 1995 - an 850 percent increase (italics theirs). In addition, what was once a predominantly Anglo-American community began to diversify. This demographic shift created divisiveness among Santa Clarita’s neighborhoods. Downtown Newhall, once the center of our thriving economy, quickly became a place where ‘those people’ lived.”
OKAY, EVERYONE, TAKE A BREATH. RELAX. READ ON...
“Gang membership in Santa Clarita has dropped from 1,300 recognized gang members in 1995 to approximately 500 in 1999.”
The source for these figures is not identified, and I don’t know if the numbers changed so drastically because we stopped “recognizing” the gang members, or if 800 of them moved away, got arrested or saw the light and joined the All America City delegation.
Certainly I do not intend to make light of gang activity, whether it’s East L.A., South Central L.A. or the apparently one-time gang-infested suburb of Santa Clarita. We at The Signal have been active participants in the Anti-Gang Task Force and will continue to support all such efforts to divert youths to positive endeavors.
Further, we unequivocally support law enforcement, locally in the form of the L.A. County Sheriff’s Department.
We do not support anything that puts this community on record as “turning around” a deteriorating area of growing gang problems and meeting the challenges of our “ethnic diversity.”
These are not the things most people think about when they think about Santa Clarita.
Will Fleet is publisher of The Signal. He can be reached at 259-1234 , ext. 291, and his email address is [email protected] .
