The possible deal to attract Nordstrom to Santa Clarita is a fascinating study in local politics.
At first glance, with comments from Mayor Jan Heidt, it appeared that the discussion hinged on whether the city would "front" $20 million in future sales tax revenue to entice Nordstrom to come to the Valencia Town Center mall.
In reality, it was never that way.
Heidt, who was the lone dissenter on the city's participation in the Hyatt Hotel deal, in essence said "No Way Jose."
Hopefully Jan will reconsider her position after the negotiations are completed and spelled out in detail. We spend a lot of time and effort trying to convince residents to shop locally. Now we have an opportunity to give them a good reason to do so, and we shouldn't let it pass.
The $20 million risk, if there's one to be taken, will be taken by Newhall Land and Farming. The city might to agree to repay the seed money out of increases in sales tax revenue generated at the mall, which in theory would be earned because of Nordstrom's presence.
Actually the deal being bandied about would repay Newhall Land with 85 percent of the new sales taxes from the mall after Nordstrom opens.
That kind of deal makes sense because it's a no-lose situation for the city. Residents get a long-anticipated, top-notch anchor store for the mall, and the city loses nothing in sales tax revenue.
The truth is the city government and its residents will come out ahead, way ahead, in the long run. Nordstrom is the kind of store that will bring shoppers to Santa Clarita from Antelope and north San Fernando valleys.
Nordstrom's position is obvious. Their people correctly figure that the store will attract sales tax revenue not only to their store but to the entire mall.
For a while after the earthquake, shoppers from those areas found their way to Santa Clarita. The Northridge Fashion Center was closed, so north SF Valley residents discovered Valencia. Antelope Valley shoppers who couldn't find everything they needed locally, also had fewer L.A. area options, so they stopped in to see us in record numbers.
Unfortunately for SClarita, the original shopping habits have basically returned as the quake fades into more distant memory.
Jill Klajic, the councilwoman who often is associated with anti-business, anti-growth postures, ironically had the most credible early response to the Nordstrom idea. She was quoted in Friday's Signal saying she "would keep an open mind. I'm told it would bring in a lot of upscale businesses, and I asked them (staff presumably) to research that very carefully. Philosophically, I'm opposed to incentives for any business, but realistically, I know this is the way things are done."
The thing to remember as the city council considers this deal is that we're talking about increases in tax revenue. The mall's current sales tax revenue base would remain untouched, continuing to go to the city.
In addition, the city would gain 15 percent of the new revenue generated by the mall as the front money is being repaid.
Finally, when the original $20 million is settled, the city would then take in all of the new revenue in perpetuity.
It costs us nothing and provides an opportunity to build a huge tax base in a city that brings in 25 percent of its sales tax revenue from the very inconsistent automotive industry. More retail business is needed to diversify the tax structure.
If that's the way the deal comes down, the city council would be foolish and shortsighted not to take it.
* * *
Will Fleet is publisher of The Signal. He can be reached at 805-259-1234 or at the e-mail address below.
