Someone asked me this week if I “was having a good time” relating to the reporting of the city’s secret meetings and subsequent commentary on the selection of the mayor of Santa Clarita.
The answer is, unequivocally, no, I am not having a good time.
These are sad times for the city of Santa Clarita. There’s no joy in Mudville when your governmental leaders have struck out.
I regard City Manager George Caravalho as a friend. He has done a lot for this city. City Attorney Carl Newton’s son Tom and nephew Jim Ewert, both attorneys with the California Newspaper Publishers Association, are good friends of mine. Mayor Jo Anne Darcy is my friend. Councilwoman Jan Heidt is a friendly acquaintance with whom I sometimes disagree on the issues, but she is a respected longtime leader in this community and I admire her for it. Councilwoman Jill Klajic openly despises this newspaper because we often report on her misguided and ill-advised behavior, but I don’t know her well enough to dislike her personally.
Therefore, when we are forced to print stories detailing how Caravalho, Carl Newton, Darcy, Klajic and Heidt violated the spirit and the letter of the California open meeting law, the Ralph M. Brown Act, there is no fun in that for me.
After watching Tuesday’s City Council meeting, it seems clear that Mayor Darcy and Councilwoman Heidt acted on advice from staff and counsel when they agreed to support Klajic’s private lawsuit against the Castaic Lake Water Agency. They were advised and comfortable at the time that it was legal to support Klajic’s lawsuit and that it was legal to conduct that business in closed session, and that it was subsequently legal to withhold that information from the public.
But let’s put the Brown Act aside and engage common sense for a moment:
How could any of them have thought that it was appropriate for Jill Klajic to vote on a matter that would directly benefit her personal lawsuit?
Do we need lawyers— whether it’s a generally competent and professional barrister like Newton or a convicted felon like Klajic’s attorney Jennifer Kilpatrick— to tell us not to devote public resources to our own private lawsuit?
Klajic has used the company line, undoubtedly advised by Newton, that the resources provided to her attorney were not significant and would be available to the general public.
That dog doesn’t hunt.
Most legal information is available to the general public. We need lawyers because they know where to get it and how to get it. Kilpatrick and Klajic apparently didn’t know where to get it or they wouldn’t have needed the city’s help. Or maybe they didn’t have the $800 that the city acknowledges was spent on the document in question.
I’m sure they didn’t have enough money to pay Carl Newton’s hourly billing rate, either. But the city does. It has plenty of your tax dollars to spend on such things.
California First Amendment Coalition attorney Terry Francke and Newton’s nephew Jim Ewert of CNPA both agree that the city stepped over the legal line when they began discussing Klajic’s lawsuit in private session.
Although they clearly violated the Brown Act, I can understand how perhaps Heidt and Darcy were convinced that it was all right to discuss the matter. I can even believe that Klajic thought she was within her legal rights at the time.
What bothers me most is that they never reported the results of their closed session actions. If they acted legally and appropriately, why hide it?
Additionally, of course, it’s deeply troubling that in the council meeting Newton, Heidt and Klajic blatantly disputed the facts of The Signal’s stories last week, but provided no facts of their own to back up their case. It’s easy to say a story isn’t true, but we’re still waiting for them to prove that anything was materially inaccurate in any of the reports published in this newspaper.
Losing her composure, Klajic snapped and even tossed a little gift back at Jo Anne Darcy after being passed over for mayor the other night. She also said Darcy “did the same thing.”
But once again, that’s not true. Yes, Darcy and Heidt did vote, wrongly, to support Klajic’s lawsuit.
The very distinct difference is that Darcy had nothing personal to gain from the vote. Klajic did, and that’s why it was not only a serious violation of the Brown Act, but an abject conflict of interest, too.
I am almost certain that in their twisted judgment on this matter, Newton, Caravalho, Heidt, Klajic and Darcy thought they were doing the right thing for their community. That’s not good enough. You have to do the right thing and do it openly.
This is an open-government society. The communists thought they were doing the right thing for their people, too. The end does not justify the means in our democracy. Please, keep our public business public.
Will Fleet is publisher of The Signal. He can be reached at 259-1234 , ext. 291, and his email address is [email protected] .
