The decades-old battle to lower the two-thirds vote requirement to a simple majority has resurfaced. Once again, “simple majority” advocates have armed themselves with the familiar battle cry that unless the two-thirds threshold for local school bond measures is reduced, our existing schools will never be repaired and much-needed new schools will never be built. Obviously, the failed lessons of past attempts have gone unlearned. Otherwise, it would be remembered that although Californians are sympathetic toward the needs of their local schools, they also realize these needs can be met without lowering the bar when it comes to raising property taxes.
George Runner
In 1883, California Gov. George Perkins’ stern warning against unrestricted taxes moved the Legislature to enact the two-thirds majority vote for all local bond measures. Since then, this protection has withstood two major statewide ballot attempts to reduce it to a simple majority. Most recently, a 1993 initiative appeared on the statewide ballot that proposed to reduce the requirement. The public responded with a resounding no. In fact, returns from the 36th Assembly District clearly report that 78 percent of the voters rejected it.
Some like to ignore these facts and continue to argue that without a reduction in the two-thirds requirement, local schools will be imperiled. Some especially like to point to last year’s $52 million failed bond measure in the William S. Hart Union High School District as a prime example of the need for lowering the threshold. I supported this bond measure and others like it because I believe it is important to invest in our local schools. The Santa Clarita Valley has demonstrated this same belief in the past as proven in other successful bond measures. Last year, Measure K, Newhall School District’s $35 million bond measure, passed with a two-thirds majority. The same holds true for other communities throughout the entire state. In March and June 1996, 24 of 32 school bonds passed across the state. In November 1995, 15 of 36 passed. Each one was approved with a two-thirds majority.
Despite what we sometimes hear, it is not necessary to lower the two-thirds threshold. Rather, it is the job of the school district to educate the community of its school needs in order to garner the support to pass local school bonds. School bonds lose because they receive too few votes, not because of the two-thirds required majority! Lowering the threshold would mean that a simple majority (50 percent plus one) would be able to determine that a tax be forced upon property owners who generally make up only a minority of voters. These debts are often repaid over a span of 20 to 30 years. This means a new generation of voters (and future homeowners) could look forward to repaying a debt they were too young to vote for in the first place. Common sense tells us that creating such a debt should not be easy to do.
We must also remember that when a school bond measure fails, there are alternatives. The measure can always re-appear on the ballot. If it fails again, school districts can look to other funding sources. Proposition 1A, the record $9.2 billion statewide bond measure that passed in November 1998, created a balanced system of financing new schools through developer fee levies, general obligation bonds, Mello-Roos bonds and state bonds. It also provides state money to match local money— limited dollars that would be wise for our school districts to utilize. If a school district is unable to raise its local share, it may request a state hardship grant to build a school. As a last resort, if the state runs out of money and cannot fund approved school district projects, school districts may increase developer fees to finish such projects.
We must fight to maintain the two-thirds threshold that has protected property owners for over a century. There is no reason to eradicate this protection simply as a result of a few failed attempts to pass school bond measures. Our communities have historically proven a genuine commitment to their local schools and, when properly informed, they will continue to pass school bonds. The two-thirds threshold strikes the best logical balance between investment in building new schools and protecting taxpayers.
Assemblyman George Runner of Palmdale represents most of the Santa Clarita Valley.
