In Gov. Gray Davis’ lexicon, government neither spends nor taxes. It merely “invests in our future.
” With all the “investing” going on, it might be time to ask how all those investments are doing.
The $104.7 billion state budget proposed by the governor consumes nearly $3,000 for every man, woman and child in the state, or $12,000 for an average family of four. Put another way, this year $9.09 out of every $100 of personal income is being taken and spent just at the state level alone— the highest percentage of income taken by state government in California’s history.
This administration has increased spending in just three years by $29.5 billion— or roughly $3,500 per family. That is as much as California’s budget grew in the prior 10 years combined.
Despite $7.3 billion of cash surplus expected to be sitting idle in state vaults by May, the governor feels it is necessary to increase the sales tax by a quarter percent, restoring it to its all-time high. Senior citizens will see their taxes rise $200 million as a result of reductions in the senior citizen property tax assistance and renters’ tax assistance programs.
But don’t worry: while seniors pay $200 million in higher property and income taxes, businesses will get $81 million in tax breaks. And even though the sales taxes on consumers will grow $1.1 billion, they can save $27 million of that— about 2-cents on the dollar— by shopping on a tax-free weekend the governor has graciously proposed.
Since the welfare reform of 1997 that was supposed to reduce welfare dramatically, health and welfare spending has ballooned 60 percent.
From state coffers, per-pupil spending will amount to $7,174 per student, or $215,220 for a classroom of 30 students. Add in all sources, and it will reach $9,200 for every public school student— a level of spending rivaled by only the most elite private schools.
That’s the amount of “investing” going on.
How are our investments doing? To answer the question, we need a point of reference: the final year of Gov. Pat Brown’s administration in 1966. Brown was voted out of office that year, in part because of charges that he was a profligate spender. And, in all fairness, he was.
The state was constructing the biggest aqueduct in history. It had just undertaken an unprecedented expansion of the state university system. It had created a state highway system that made California’s freeways the model for the world. Perhaps most enviable from today’s perspective, it had authorized major hydroelectric and nuclear facilities that promised a limitless supply of clean and cheap electricity. Pat Brown delivered one of the finest public schools systems in the country and a mental health system that has yet to be rivaled. Spacious new homes at a fraction of today’s prices were springing up in new communities across the state.
To produce all this, in 1966 Gov. Brown spent $250 for every man, woman and child in California, or about $1,300 in today’s dollars. Gov. Davis is now “investing” $3,000 per person, or two and a half times more. In inflation-adjusted dollars, Brown spent about $3,000 for every student in the public schools from all sources: local, state and federal. Local bonds passed at just half the rate they do today, the population was growing twice as fast, and yet we easily kept pace with our school housing needs. Our students ranked near the top of the nation in student achievement.
Gray Davis is spending $9,200 per student from all sources and yet our schools are chronically overcrowded and we consistently rank near the bottom of national student achievement. The only area where Davis is spending less than Pat Brown is for transportation. Gov. Brown spent about $250 per capita on transportation in 1999-adjusted dollars. Gov. Davis will spend about $187 per capita.
Brown spent our transportation money to build the finest highway system in the world. Davis’ Caltrans director has announced “the era of highway construction is over.”
With Davis’ first three budgets, California is now taxing more and delivering less than it has ever taxed and delivered in its history. The words of Shakespeare’s Cassius are haunting: “Age, thou art shamed. Rome, thou hast lost the breed of noble bloods.”
State Sen. Tom McClintock, R-Thousand Oaks, represents the 19th State Senate District, which includes western portions of the Santa Clarita Valley.
