"Perhaps the bleakest fact of all is that the death penalty is imposed not only in a freakish and discriminatory manner, but also in some cases upon defendants who are actually innocent."
— Justice William J. Brennan, Jr.
Last September, two days before Anthony Porter — a death row inmate with an IQ of 51 — was to be executed, the Illinois State Supreme Court granted him a reprieve so his mental fitness could be evaluated. It was a lucky break, not just for Porter, but for the state of Illinois as well, because they would have otherwise sent an innocent man to his death.
Because of Porter's stay of execution, he lived long enough for new evidence to be uncovered as to his innocence. First, a key eyewitness for the prosecution recanted his testimony with allegations that the police pressured him to connect Porter to the crime. Next, a number of leads pointed to another suspect who, after being tracked down by a private detective, confessed on videotape to the deaths for which Porter had been convicted. It was enough evidence for a Circuit Court judge to release Porter from prison pending further investigation. After 17 years on death row, Porter went home.
Porter owes his reclaimed freedom not to the diligence of the judicial system, but to a Northwestern University class in investigative journalism, which selected Porter's case for review as a class project.
This was not the first time Professor David Protess and his journalism class uncovered the evidence that freed innocent men. In 1996, four other men were released from prison after serving 18 years. They, too, can credit Professor Protess' students for uncovering the evidence that freed them.
And it is far from the first time a death row inmate was found innocent after receiving a death sentence.
Nationwide since 1973, a total of 69 people have been found innocent and released from death row. All too often these mistakes were discovered not through the normal process of courtroom appeals, but by the efforts of journalists, attorneys and new scientific techniques such as DNA testing.
Sixty-nine wrongful death penalty sentences are an unacceptably high number. One is an unacceptably high number. It leaves little doubt that people have died at the hands of the state because they did not have the benefit of someone to investigate in-depth the circumstances of their convictions. By one account, 23 people have been executed in the United States since 1900, only to later be proven innocent.
Perhaps the biggest flaw in our justice system is that we mere mortals administer it, subjecting it to our human frailties. The Chicago Tribune reports of 381 homicide cases where misconduct by the prosecution, such as concealing evidence or presenting false evidence, led to reversals of conviction. This month in Arkansas, the governor commuted one death sentence after a juror admitted he voted for conviction out of fear of being ostracized in his community. And because most of our prosecutors and judges depend on being re-elected, there is a built-in incentive for them to discount evidence of innocence in order to have a more impressive conviction record.
Many valid arguments have been made against the death penalty over the years: Capital punishment is not a deterrent — when compared to states that have abolished the death penalty, those that retain it have a slightly higher homicide rate; Capital punishment is not more economical — a Florida study shows us that the cost of an execution is six times the cost of imprisoning someone for life. But no argument against the death penalty is as strong as the fact that we can never be certain that we don't execute innocent people.
And yet the popularity of the death penalty in the United States is growing at a frenzied rate. Pre-election debates between candidates are dominated with challenges of who has the longer history of support for capital punishment. Legislators pander for re-election votes with new laws that will hasten executions and limit the appeals process. The number of crimes to which the death penalty can be applied is rising, and the minimum age for a death sentence is dropping (to as low as 13 in Mississippi). This tightening of defense resources and the increasing number of death sentences bring with them an even greater likelihood of innocent people being executed.
The only way to prevent the execution of innocent people is to abolish the death penalty. Capital punishment is ineffective as a deterrent, costly, uncivilized and inhumane. Its abolition is long overdue.
* * *
Rick Lott is a Santa Clarita resident and Democratic activist. If you would like to write a guest column, call Tim Whyte at 259-1234, ext. 234.
