"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances."
— The First Amendment to the Constitution of the United States
Forty-five simple, concise words conveying much of what our country stands for. And yet literally thousands and thousands of legal opinions have been issued explaining just exactly what those 45 words mean. I would like to concentrate for a few minutes on the section regarding speech, the press, and peaceable assembly.
Many of you may remember my uncle, Robert Matern, from the first article I wrote several weeks ago. He was a Marine who gave his life in service to his country in Vietnam. I think he would be somewhat disheartened by what has been taking place in Orange County over the past couple weeks.
As I'm sure you know by now, Truong Van Tran owns a video store. He wants to hang a picture of Ho Chi Minh and a flag of North Vietnam in the window of his store. A vocal majority from the surrounding area is taking issue with his intentions. As a result, Mr. Tran now has to move to and from his own business with a police escort.
He has been beaten at least once, hit on several occasions, and if my memory serves me correctly, hospitalized on one occasion. As of this writing, he has been advised by the police and his lawyer to close his business for a three-day cooling-off period!
Before I go any further let me make one thing perfectly clear. I do not support Ho Chi Minh nor communism. Ho Chi Minh was responsible for the deaths of hundreds of thousands of people, including my Uncle Bobby. Communism is a repressive environment that discourages individuality and summarily punishes dissidence.
Now I've heard several arguments about why this is not a free speech issue. First, that this is at a business and not his personal residence. After all, it is open to the public and offensive material should not be displayed. Another one explains how divisive a picture of Hitler and a swastika would be within a Jewish community. The problems with both of these arguments is, neither is mentioned in the actual First Amendment!
Nowhere does it say that free speech does not extend to the business or public side of society. The amendment makes no mention of speech being divisive or unpopular. In fact, I believe the amendment was written for exactly the opposite reason. That is, to afford protection to an individual or group who wanted to speak against the majority. To allow for discussion of unpopular ideas and thoughts. In fact, in evaluating the spirit of the amendment, I must believe that our founding fathers would find the walking on the flag while it is displayed on the ground, (a practice I find rude and abhorrent), to be more tolerable than the treatment afforded Truong Van Tran.
So who is wrong? I believe it is the people carrying on the violent protest against Mr. Tran. And I believe they should be held legally accountable for their actions. It seems they have forgotten why so many Americans went to their country. Worse yet, they have forgotten why so many Americans did not return. They have lost sight of the kind of person Ho Chi Minh was and what he did to them, their families and their country. (Of course many will never forget the actual atrocities but rather the ideology that brought them about).
In attempting to protest against a despot, they have taken on some of the attributes of the very tyrant they oppose. In a very real sense those who are attempting to harm Mr. Tran are following in the footsteps of Ho Chi Minh.
Even though Mr. Tran has the right to display material that may be deemed by some as offensive, his neighbors are well within their rights to protest. The protest, however, should be a peaceful one. The picketing of Mr. Tran's business. The agreement within the neighborhood not to patronize the store. This is the way to register one's disagreement with someone else's ideas within our system of government.
What's the old saying, "Hit them where it hurts — in the pocketbook."
Peaceably letting Truong Van Tran know that honoring someone like Ho Chi Minh cannot be tolerated gives more credibility to their cause. Peaceful protests demonstrate something that we as Americans all too often forget. With every right that our forefathers gave us and was protected by our young men and women, comes a responsibility. A responsibility to that right. This portion of the First Amendment, "... or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble ..." has been unmercifully dissected. But in trying to decide what we have the right to say, we have forgotten the responsibility to honor the right of those who disagree with us. When you accept the right you cannot give up the responsibility.
If Truong Van Tran is indeed honoring Ho Chi Minh, and if he is a communist, I cannot agree with his political or social views. But as an American, and for the sake of my uncle, I must accept the responsibility of protecting his right to peacefully express those views.
* * *
Don Matern is a Santa Clarita resident. "Do the Right Thing" rotates among several local Republicans, and appears Mondays. If you would like to write a guest column, call Tim Whyte at 259-1234, ext. 234.
