America and the world have changed dramatically in the closing decades of the 20th century. The old industrial order is rapidly yielding to the networked "New Economy" of the 21st century. Our political and governing systems, however, remain stuck in the same old liberal vs. conservative debates of the past.
The Democratic Leadership Council, founded in 1985 by a group of moderate, business-oriented Democrats determined to change the philosophy of the Democratic Party, has been instrumental in modernizing politics and government. Its political analysis and policy innovations have provided a feasible alternative to the worn-out dogmas of traditional liberalism and conservatism.
This alternative approach, labeled the "Third Way" by the Progressive Policy Institute, a think tank affiliated with the DLC, is a blending of conservative and liberal principles. It embraces the notion that government should promote equal opportunity for all while granting special privilege for none. It stresses an ethic of mutual responsibility that equally rejects the politics of entitlement and the politics of social abandonment. And it provides a new approach to governing that empowers citizens to act for themselves, rather than relying on the government for the answers to their problems.
This approach stresses technological innovation, competitive enterprise and education rather than the redistribution of wealth or laissez faire economics. In the area of values, it embraces "tolerant traditionalism," honoring traditional moral and family values while rejecting attempts to impose them on others. It favors an enabling rather than a bureaucratic government; expanding choices for citizens; using the market to achieve public ends; and encouraging civic and community institutions to play a larger role in public life.
For Democrats, this Third Way philosophy does not mean abandoning such traditional principles as equal opportunity, civil rights, cultural tolerance, an active public sector, or a special commitment to Americans in need. But, it does mean rethinking the approach to these principles, just as Democrats have rethought public policies at other great turning points in our history like the industrial revolution, the Great Depression and the civil rights movement.
It means pulling the Democratic Party away from the left and toward the center, paying less attention to liberal special interests — such as labor unions, feminists, gays and minorities — and more attention to the "forgotten middle class." It also means abandoning the tendency of traditional liberals to place the expansion of government programs at the top of their agenda, even when such programs no longer promote the goals they were originally designed to achieve or reflect the values they were originally intended to vindicate.
Although this approach challenges the left to adjust to the changing times, it also creates a new and more vigorous intellectual and political competition for the right. For decades, political conservatives have prospered simply by criticizing the big government excesses and cultural eccentricities of traditional liberals. By removing these easy targets, the "Third Way" forces conservatives to try to articulate a positive governing agenda, which they are currently unable to offer with any degree of unity or coherence.
Most broadly, the Third Way represents an acceptance of two historical truths that many on the Left have been slow to acknowledge. The first is that capitalism is the best economic system yet devised for creating growth and efficiently allocating resources. The second is that two-parent families, nurturing such values as faith, work, personal responsibility, civility and openness to new ideas, are the best social unit for raising children.
But at the same time, the Third Way rejects the right's tendency to turn capitalism into a religion, confusing means with ends, and abandoning the public responsibility to shape market forces to produce broad-based economic and social progress. It also means rejecting the right's reluctance to support families and reinforce mainstream values with public resources that give them the tools they need to do what they do best: create opportunity, instill responsibility, and embody community.
Taken together, these ideas create a new political ideology that uses the market to pursue public goals; that combines fidelity to traditional values with a determination to shape rapid economic and technological change; and that insists on organizing public resources for the common good while recognizing the increasing impotence of large, centralized bureaucracies and the increasing importance of self-governing individuals and community institutions. It means replacing the welfare system with a competitive employment system. It means saving public education through choice, competition and accountability for measurable results.
This is the future the Democratic Party must embrace: a middle-of-the-road philosophy predicated upon fiscal conservatism, free trade and investment in training and education. A philosophy not grounded in the left or the right, but in the centrist politics of the New Democrats that benefits society as a whole.
* * *
Ernie Tichenor is a Santa Clarita resident. 'Those Damn Democrats' appears Tuesdays, and rotates among several local Democrats. If you would like to write a guest column, call Tim Whyte at 259-1234, ext. 234.
