Last Friday’s Signal editorial (“Klajic and SCOPE Stand in Way of New School Construction,” March 23) makes clear what many of us have known for some time: that SCOPE and its anti-growth allies will do anything— even block the building of new schools— to prevail in its single-minded grudge against The Newhall Land and Farming Co.
There are many interesting aspects to this hypocrisy:
1. Despite the CLWA’s sound practice of purchasing water entitlements for our future needs (what Mike Kotch sneeringly calls “paper water”), Mr. Kotch, Ed Dunn and Lynne Plambeck continue to advocate policies and practices that have an Alice-in-Wonderland quality. Thus, SCOPE and its allies want to prevent the building of new homes and schools unless and until the water for them is actually here— requiring reservoir storage we don’t now have and couldn’t possibly build without rabid opposition from... SCOPE and its allies.
2. Mr. Kotch contends that each bonded indebtedness for each water entitlement purchased by CLWA should be subject to an expensive and time-consuming plebiscite. At a minimum, of course, this would defeat the purpose of having elected CLWA public representatives— which is for our representatives to make critical business judgments on water entitlement purchases based on their knowledge and experience. But the real reason Mr. Kotch advocates this practice is that it would allow SCOPE and its allies to transform every plebiscite on those water purchasing decisions into an emotional referendum on local growth. This would effectively prevent CLWA from purchasing enough water entitlements to meet the needs of even the existing homes and schools in this valley. Thus, SCOPE and Mr. Kotch propose to use taxpayer money to prevent and delay CLWA’s efforts to meet the water needs of local taxpayers.
3. SCOPE’s recent court victory may have warmed the cockles of this valley’s anti-growth hearts, but it came at the expense of judicial sanity and constitutional order. Think about it: a Ventura County judge has ordered a Los Angeles County developer to stop work on a Los Angeles County bridge over a Los Angeles County stream based on alleged habitat destruction in Los Angeles County. This is like taking a boundary dispute with your neighbor to court in San Francisco. Now it so happens that we have judges in Los Angeles County whose job it is to decide such allegations. And if your lawyer proposed charging you good money to take this dispute to a judge in another county you would tell her to take a hike.
But you might well pursue such a strategy if your purpose was not to win the war, but only to win enough battles to cause more delay in the building of the roads and bridges that are intended to ease access to new and existing homes and schools. And that is exactly SCOPE’s strategy in its war of attrition against Newhall Land.
4. The sleeper in all of this is SCOPE’s failure to take stands on real issues that directly affect the citizens of Santa Clarita:
(a) SCOPE made only the most tepid comments about the recent trash contract decision. It could have actively promoted the possibility of the city acquiring 800-plus acres of Elsmere Canyon, but it never lifted a finger to do so. In this, SCOPE allied itself with Waste Management, the world’s largest trash company. This company is a near monopoly in the local trash business, and it may well have generated inaccurate trash diversion figures. SCOPE may not be interested in such mundane issues as recycling and trash diversion, but one would think SCOPE would at least express some interest in public ownership in the single most symbolic piece of undeveloped land in this valley. Instead it stayed on the sidelines and sat on its hands.
(b) SCOPE has likewise signaled its non-opposition to the phased development of Porta Bella— the most polluted site in the entire Santa Clara River Valley. In this SCOPE has allied itself with RFI/Santa Clarita LLC, a developer who (unlike Newhall Land) lacks the financial resources to honor its existing development agreement. That agreement requires RFI/SCLLC, before beginning any development, to remove the 275 hazardous substances from the soil and water, and also to remove all remaining live explosives and depleted uranium from the property. But SCOPE supports RFI/SCLLC’s proposal that it should be allowed to begin phased development as a kind of pay-as-you-go homebuilder. Yet, if Newhall Land asked to be relieved by such half-measures from performing its obligations under an existing development agreement, you can be certain SCOPE would be crying “Foul!” from here to Ventura.
It’s likely everyone in this valley would like to draw a line and absolutely cap development here at a certain level. That’s the emotion SCOPE seeks to exploit. But this is America, and people still have a right to develop their land for its highest and best use. SCOPE’s dirty little secret is that it is highly selective about whom it attacks (it isn’t satisfied unless its attacks somehow hurt Newhall Land or CLWA), and where it attacks (if it can’t find a sympathetic judge in Los Angeles County, it will gladly go judge-shopping in Ventura).
SCOPE is hypocritical in its ends and dishonest in its means of achieving them— and it is just cruel enough to deny our children the new schools they so desperately need.
John F. Grannis is a Santa Clarita resident.
