Critics (including several columnists in this paper) assert that SCOPE has a focus and vendetta against The Newhall Land and Farming Co. They are half-correct: SCOPE has given Newhall Land a lot of focus. Why? Because Newhall Land is the biggest broker of land-use changes in the Santa Clarita Valley.
Newhall Land routinely processes changes in the character of the Santa Clarita Valley that add anywhere from 1,000 to 21,000 new residences in our Valley per project. No other developer operates in the SCV on this scale, and the limited resources that SCOPE has are best put to use where they will have the greatest effect.
Even so, SCOPE has criticized other developers and projects that were smaller in scale but were clearly a bad idea, and has endorsed developments that were appropriate and timely, including some by Newhall Land.
The critics are wrong in suggesting a vendetta. SCOPE recognizes that Newhall Land, as the biggest land broker in the area, can provide the leadership and precedents under which other developers can be guided for consideration of the environment, traffic, schools and simple amenities that make a community better. With Newhall Land being such a strong presence in the Santa Clarita Valley, our job of providing oversight has actually been made simpler. We can concentrate on the Monolith, and need not divide our resources among many smaller companies.
SCOPE does not wish Newhall Land to disappear as a company (they are perfectly capable of doing that by themselves, once the land is gone), and any imaginations that SCOPE would overcome Newhall Land represent "The Mouse That Roared" on steroids.
Newhall Land has done some good in their planning and development in the SCV, and a number of SCOPE members live in Newhall Land projects because they like what was done. Newhall Land was smart to hire a master architect to establish fundamental planning concepts and philosophies; and their customers like the paseos.
But Newhall Land has also committed serious errors. Mistake No. 1 was the lack of an adequate interchange on Interstate 5 for the Valencia Industrial Center. Here is a major employment center that completely forgot about freeway access. Mistake No. 2 was no corporate concern and response when Proposition 13 was passed and local infrastructure needs should have been immediately transferred to impact fees. Tom Lee says that "Newhall Land has always been focused on regional and local infrastructure," yet Newhall Land was more than glad to "coast" on a free ride for a decade without providing mitigation fees from new development. A SCOPE lawsuit against Newhall Land over the Westridge project finally, after over a decade of irresponsibility, got decent fees for schools and libraries. Now the Legislature, supported by Newhall Land lobbyists, is trying to renege again on schools.
Newhall Land's declaration that they now fully mitigate school and library impacts of their developments did not occur because of Newhall Land's sudden change of heart from their past practices (which was to pay the minimum and none at all, respectively). It came about because organizations like SCOPE challenged them in court and won.
As a corporation developing thousands of acres into billions of dollars, Newhall Land has operated in a manner Machiavelli would have admired. They establish a strong presence as a contributor in local causes and charities. They have, in the last decade, organized contributions and support to political campaigns in nearly every local, regional, state and federal office so that they have a "friend" in place everywhere. (Newhall Land and their associates were significant contributors against Santa Clarita becoming an independent city.)
These are not stupid people. They produce and market their product to attract buyers. They control or influence those who give them governmental approval for their interests. This influence is pervasive at the local level and extends much higher in government.
When all is said and done, Newhall Land, kept under control, is an asset to our community. The damage is done, however, when Newhall Land is not kept under control, but instead, controls.
* * *
Michael A. Kotch is president of SCOPE (Santa Clarita Organization for Planning the Environment). If you would like to write a guest column, call Tim Whyte at 259-1234, ext. 234.
