The Newhall Ranch proposal has a great many geological and seismic problems that have not yet been addressed, and until they are, the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors should not approve the project. The chief geologist for the project testified to the effect that geologic studies were done and expressed confidence that his work was complete and they were ready for the construction permit. In further testimony, he assured his listeners that he and his client would only build within the legal distance of a known earthquake fault, and that after the permits have been issued, if they uncover a buried earthquake fault, they promise to mitigate the situation.
This is a bad idea in the light of past judgments made by this geologist on a nearby subdivision. To illustrate, last spring during a public debate on certain geologic aspects of the Newhall Ranch region, between myself and this geologist, I stated that I had prepared an earthquake fault map of the Stevenson Ranch area during the 1960s. After the 1994 earthquake, I examined the damage in Stevenson Ranch and it was along faults which I had mapped 30 years ago. I observed damaged homes right in a fault zone! During our debate, my geologist friend proudly stated he had done the geology on Stevenson Ranch. It is very unusual that an experienced geologist would fail to see and map obvious earthquake faults which were mapped many years before. Through this oversight and neglect on the part of a licensed geologist, many Stevenson Ranch homes were damaged.
Last year, this same geologist was saying, "Trust me, the Newhall Ranch is geologically stable and it's safe to build homes on." Our geologist friend made a bad judgment call on Stevenson Ranch, just two miles south of Newhall Ranch. Should the Board of Supervisors approve Newhall Ranch without a second opinion? I hope not!
Major faults are located within the region. The San Gabriel fault lies to the northeast and has a north branch in the Castaic area. This fault also has a branch which trends north from Charlie Canyon and forms the western edge of the Castaic Lake Dam. The western edge of the dam is resting in a fault zone. The western edge of the St. Francis Dam was also built in a fault zone and the dam failed in 1928. When the dam broke, a 20-foot wall of water began cascading down the creek, going right along Newhall Ranch, toward the Pacific Ocean and Ventura, killing hundreds of people and destroying lots of property. If there was movement along the Castaic-dam fault, the Castaic Lake dam could fail and Newhall Ranch might be hit with a 40-foot wall of water because Castaic Lake holds a lot more water than did the lake behind the St. Francis Dam. The Van Norman Dam, some 10 miles south of Newhall Ranch, also failed during the 1971 Sylmar earthquake because its western edge was also built in a fault. The Upper Van Norman Dam, which was built to replace the failed Van Norman Dam, was also built in a fault zone.
A "disturbed" tectonic belt, composed of faulted and folded rock, lies between the Interstate 5 and State Route 14 interchange and Martinez Canyons. During the 1994 earthquake extensive damage was caused to structures within this earthquake-fault belt. The I-5 and SR 14 and the I-5 Gavin Canyon bridge collapsed, 237 homes behind the Hampton Inn along with other structures within the 300- to 500-foot-wide fault zone were severely damaged. The earthquake caused a surface fault-rupture within the earthquake-fault zone on Newhall Ranch.
If there was movement on the Chiquita blind thrust fault (on the northern edge of Newhall Ranch) and a quake occurred next to a fully developed Newhall Ranch, there is potential for major damage!
1. The Castaic dam could fail.
2. The garbage in the Chiquita landfill could shift and release toxic pollutants and methane gas. These pollutants could contaminate ground water and and be hazardous to Newhall Ranch residences.
3. The plugs in the abandoned oil wells in the Newhall Potrero Oil field could leak. The Newhall Ranch community will be built on top of an abandoned oil field. Methane gas leakage from abandoned oil wells at the bottom of the proposed Potrero Lake would be very difficult and expensive to fix.
4. Earthquake damage could be caused to homes and businesses in Newhall Ranch.
Damage to Newhall Ranch would probably be more severe than the damage in Stevenson Ranch during the 1994 earthquake because of the close proximity to the earthquake epicenter.
I hope I never hear Newhall Ranch referred to as the Love Canal of the Santa Clarita Valley!
* * *
Kaye McCown is a Castaic resident.
