With Dr. Jack Kevorkian and his unhappy-looking attorney Michael Schwartz making the news recently by offering up kidneys from an assisted suicide, many people overcame their initial repulsion to such an idea long enough to wonder, just for a moment, whether they could ever agree to receiving such a transplant if their lives depended on it. They may have also questioned whether, under certain circumstances, they would want the right to give up their life with the knowledge that their kidney would be used to save the life of another. As current of a debate in modern culture as this is, the ethical issues are rooted deep in the history of philosophy.
One might assume that Socrates, as portrayed by Plato in "The Trial and Death of Socrates," would not be against suicide. After all, he acts against his friends' wishes and voluntarily drinks hemlock, choosing to die rather than defy the judgment of the State.
And before downing the cup of poison, Socrates waxes poetic about the afterlife, claiming it is something to look forward to rather than something to fear. However, looking at it from another perspective, it was the government that ordered Socrates' death, so perhaps this isn't a suicide at all. He had a choice, but in his view going against the State and sneaking away with his friends meant going against his principles, and that would have been more destructive to his soul than the simple death of his body. Perhaps there is a parallel here to modern people with chronic pain and terminal diseases who believe that not committing suicide may be a greater disrespect to their lives than ending those lives peacefully while they can. Comparing Socrates' death to assisted suicide is not easy because Socrates was obeying the law out of principle, taking his punishment, and modern patients seeking assisted suicide feel they must break the law, out of principle.
The classic match-up in this dispute is between deontological and consequential moral theories. Or, between those who believe, "the ends do not justify the means" and those who believe, "the means are justified by the ends."
Kant, the philosophic hero of deontology, stood firmly against suicide, even if the patient suffers terrible physical or emotional pain. To run from such pain and escape in death would be to turn your back on life. Often we learn important lessons only by going through hard times, and if everyone commits suicide when the going gets rough, soon there won't be any people around to worry about ethics at all. More than this, it was irrational and immoral to Kant for a person to use a human being as a means to an end, and that includes using your own death as a means to ending your pain.
Mill could hardly be called a champion of suicide rights, but he had considerable trouble showing how his ethical system, based on consequences, could condemn it. Modern consequentialists have picked up on that and used Mill's theory to argue that euthanasia may be the only moral choice in many cases of terminal illness. There will be less pain, less resources expended and less stress for the doctors and family members who know there is nothing they can do to help. Theoretically, the consequentialists add up all the good and bad elements that result from each moral choice and pick the one with the most good. Maximizing the good things is accomplished in this case by minimizing the bad things. Death, in these extreme situations, is looked upon with a smile.
For my part, I'd have to say it seems pretty obvious that there are some drastic cases where a peaceful, assisted death by suicide would be the more respectful choice for how to end your days. And I would take a kidney from Kevorkian if my life depended on it. But as I write that, my mind flashes back to scenes from "Soylent Green" and "Coma," and I wonder what people will want to salvage from assisted suicide bodies next. The problem is we would have to trust a government to protect us from abuse. Socrates trusted the government, and look what it got him.
Hemlock, anyone?
* * *
Lee French is a Santa Clarita resident.
