California must provide bold leadership to give our children the education excellence they deserve. Since 1995, California has slowly implemented new reforms, which included reducing class-sizes , improving classroom curriculum, and lengthening the school year. As successful as these have been, the fact remains our students still have some of the lowest
George Runner
reading scores in the nation.
While accountability may be the answer to the state’s failing education system, true accountability cannot begin until the state shifts control from Sacramento back to California’s local school boards. Over the last two decades, local school boards have lost most of their authority to determine how state funds are spent. This loss of flexibility has taken its toll.
As long as Sacramento continues to micro-manage our schools, accountability is not possible. Only when school districts are given the ability to be accountable can they meet the world-class standards the state has set for its students. In this year’s budget, I have proposed to increase discretionary spending for schools by $1 billion. This proposal would increase the authority of school districts by allowing them to design their own approaches to education.
If we are committed to holding schools accountable, the state needs to allow local officials to spend their resources based on the specific needs of their students. Gov. Davis’ new “accountability system” falls short of the reforms necessary to establish true accountability. Davis’ proposal does not allow additional flexibility and only holds schools hostage to Sacramento’s rules and bureaucratic red tape. In order for this new “accountability system” to work, we need to trust school officials elected by our communities to make the right decisions based on the needs of their students. Unfortunately, school districts lack the flexibility to develop state-funded programs into educational strategies that improve overall student achievement.
The state allocates funding to schools for more than 60 different categorical programs. In fact, over 50 percent of education dollars are allocated for these specific state-mandated programs. Categorical education programs are programs funded by the state to address specified needs. Each categorical program has its own rules and guidelines. Flexibility is lost when school districts are forced to comply with complex, detailed requirements. For instance, if a school needs reading textbooks and the state allocates funding to purchase only math books, the school faces the dilemma of either not using the funds or buying math books when reading books are needed. California has approximately 1,000 school districts. Clearly, a one-size-fits-all approach does not benefit every district’s unique needs.
In another effort to create more flexibility for local school districts, I have introduced a measure this year to streamline many of the education programs into five block grants. These block grants will give more flexibility to school districts by breaking down the “red tape” barriers districts face to receive funding.
Schools will be able to shift funding from a program they do not use to a program that better reflects the needs of their students.
There are no simple solutions to fix California’s ailing schools. However, a top-down education policy from Sacramento is not working.
When Sacramento dictates all of the rules and decisions, it is difficult to hold schools accountable. It is time to try a new approach by reallocating spending priorities from Sacramento back to local school districts. In doing so, we must be ready to stand firm and hold our districts accountable. We can’t have it both ways— either we believe Sacramento should micromanage local school decisions, or local officials who understand the uniqueness of our communities should make those decisions.
Assemblyman George Runner represents Lancaster, Palmdale and Santa Clarita.
