ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Guest Commentary

The truth about Endangered Species Act

John Grannis’ recent diatribe (“Right here, right now,” July 23) against the Endangered Species Act might better be titled, “Wrong here, wrong now,” for it contains distortions of fact that would be laughable were it not for the fact that many innocent readers may mistake this misinformation for fact when it is packaged as a feature column of the Signal.

He cites a number of examples of how the ESA values bugs and bunnies more than humans, in support of his conclusion that “the protection of species threatens the lives and livelihoods of real people, and in America that should never be so.”

Whew. “Real people in America” versus “species” is a mythical battle often conjured up by the Wrong on the Right— waving a big flag in a blast of hot air. Of course, the battle is mostly in their minds.

Nationwide, in seven years for which accurate statistical data are available, there were 94,113 land uses which involved the ESA, of which 2,719 (about 3 percent) required consultation with federal agencies to determine potential impacts; of these, 352 (0.04 percent) were found to jeopardize endangered species, and only 54 (0.006 percent) were blocked from taking the proposed action.

Just 54 out of more than 94,000 projects halted by the ESA in seven years’ time? That’s 99.9 percent permitted to proceed. How onerous is that? I do not know what those 54 halted projects were, but overall, the numbers would seem to me to suggest that the ESA protections may be a bit too lenient.

Anyway, those are the numbers, now onward to the truth behind Mr. Grannis’ fairy tales.

First, the Taung Ming-Lin story. This is an apocryphal story, told and retold— almost always incorrectly— as a “classic example” of what is wrong with the ESA: poor immigrant farmer buys a little farm, while plowing field accidentally kills rat, 25 jackbooted paratroopers [yes, this is part of the legend] in helicopters swoop down on his farm and haul him off to jail. Pretty scary stuff for the poor little farmer. Sounds like Big Brother has gone awry.

But, of course, the facts differ a bit from the Limbaughian fable. Taung Ming-Lin is a Taiwanese businessman who, through his corporation, paid $1.5 million for some arid land in the San Joaquin Valley, on which several endangered species were known to reside.

The resource agencies sent letters to Ming-Lin , informing him of the presence of sensitive public resources and the need to obtain permits prior to altering the land, and agents also personally contacted his son and foreman. Ming-Lin clearly understood the need for permits— which other landowners had already obtained— to work this land without violating the ESA. But, he consistently ignored the agencies, apparently preferring to challenge them, and willfully destroyed endangered species. A warrant was served by four wardens and biologists from the U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service and California Department of Fish and Game, who did indeed find dead specimens of the endangered Tipton kangaroo rat in the ploughed areas, and then did impound the tractor and disc used to kill them. The government did elect to prosecute his corporation, but Taung Ming-Lin personally has not been charged. Clearly, the facts aren’t as colorful, or dramatic, as the fiction.

Also, Grannis rails about the recent designation of 2.8 million acres of “private property as critical habitat for the red-legged frog, prohibiting any use of that land that fails to prove that its effect on the frog will be benign.” Nonsense. Much of the land designated is public, not private, and the critical habitat designation applies only to proposed land uses that involve federal agencies, and so has no bearing upon purely private actions on private lands.

What, then, does the ESA do, and why do the Grannises of the world vilify it so? It is just another regulatory act, one of tens of thousands that govern our actions, and one that applies to so few of us that the chances are no one you know, outside the development community, will ever be directly affected by it in any negative way. There are many thousands of laws protecting humans from humans. There also are thousands of laws protecting our property, water and other rights, and thousands more expediting hunting, trapping, fishing, logging, mining and other uses of natural resources for sport or personal gain. There are a few laws that generally protect wildlife from harm, or regulate seasons in which it is legal to kill things, but the only laws ever passed that specifically protect a particular wildlife species from endangerment or direct destruction at the hand of man are the state and federal ESAs. These regulations were passed in recognition of the fact that two centuries of virtually

← Back to 2001

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-df:/editorial/guest/0701/073101a.html.
System
date-file pages (/desk/MMYY/MMDDYY.html)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 793 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
datefile:START_STORY
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • url:datefile_editorial
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 3, national 0