Envision an auto plant where workers are encouraged to send parts up the assembly line, regardless of whether they are assembled correctly. A company that cares about its future wouldn't do this to its cars, yet much of the American public school system is doing it to its children. It's called "social promotion," and its effects are devastating.
Social promotion is the practice of advancing a student to the next grade based on age, rather than academic achievement. Intended to foster self-esteem, social promotion has made a mockery of the diploma while eroding public confidence in our schools. Under this destructive practice, hard work and achievement give way to a positive self-image as the link to educational success.
The practice dates back to the late 1970s. It was thought that keeping students of the same age together would prevent them from being labeled as failures, and protect them from ridicule by classmates. Eventually, parents would pressure school administrators to allow their child to advance, wary of the shame their son or daughter might face if they were held back.
Social promotion has become the rule, not the exception. In 1990, for example, the National Association of Elementary School Principals listed development of a "positive self-image" first among the characteristics of a good early childhood education. When an association of school administrators makes this kind of endorsement, what are we to think about the priorities of those who educate our children?
Ignoring a student's failures sends the message that achievement isn't important and that schools don't believe students can master their assigned tasks, even with greater effort. As the subject matter grows more difficult, students without adequate preparation have a virtual impossibility of ever catching up. They continue to fall farther behind and leave school ill-equipped for college or the workplace. You know something has gone terribly wrong when some students can't even read their diploma on graduation day!
If building self-esteem is the goal, how will students feel when they can't land a decent job? Self-esteem means valuing yourself because you have accomplished a task, not because the standards have been lowered, but because you did the necessary work. Students who know they will be advanced, regardless of how poorly they perform, lose the desire to learn and the will to exert even a minimal effort.
The temptation to ignore problems instead of solving them is always great. But years after its implantation, the problems of social promotion are becoming all too apparent.
Many school districts in the state report more than half of their students are reading below grade level. In fact, nearly 50 percent of incoming students to the California State University system, composed of a third of high school graduates, need remedial math or English classes to be able to perform in mainstream college courses. This is unacceptable!
As bad as social promotion is, however, merely prohibiting it and retaining students in their current grade is not the answer. There must be intervention before students fail. After-school tutoring, mandatory summer school, well-trained teachers and performance standards are crucial.
Efforts to combat this problem in California are ongoing. The California Assessment Act of 1995 mandated the development and adoption of rigorous content and performance standards in the core curriculum areas of reading, writing, mathematics, history and science for grades K-12. As a result, Standardized Testing and Reporting was established in 1997. STAR requires that all California public school districts use a single standardized test to measure each student in grades 2 through 11. Additionally, Assemblywoman Lynne Leach is the author of legislation which would prohibit social promotion in California's public schools.
These important steps will allow us to stop cheating our children and diluting our educational system. Within the system, there are very few consequences for students who fail academically. But the consequences become painfully obvious as they graduate into society without the skills they need to survive.
The promise of a quality education is the promise of a brighter, more prosperous future for our children. Let's make sure they're prepared for responsible citizenship, further learning and productive employment. Let's not fail our students by passing them when it's clear they aren't ready for advancement.
* * *
Pete Knight, R-Palmdale, represents most of the Santa Clarita Valley in the state Senate. If you would like to write a guest column, call Tim Whyte at 259-1234, ext. 234.
