I'm holding two letters in my hands. One is from Superintendent of Public Instruction Delaine Eastin, stating that California is 37th in the nation when it comes to per-pupil spending on education. The other is from our State Assemblyman, George Runner, in which he states that we are ranked "significantly higher than that"; that California is 28th in the nation in per-pupil spending. And I'm left perplexed ... could this possibly be a meaningful argument?
Does Microsoft debate how much better off they would be should only 56 percent of their competitors spend more on research than they do as opposed to 74 percent? Do the Lakers wonder about the impact of having 56 percent of their competitors spend more on players than they do as opposed to 74 percent? Of course not. Organizations that dwell on where in the lower half of things they should be ranked are doomed to failure. Successful organizations are those that maximize investments in their product. They don't starve their investment opportunities, they feed them. All of the great organizations — Microsoft, the Lakers, the Dodgers and Harvard University to name a few — are characterized by their willingness to plow capital back into their organizations, to develop the best products and to attract the best talent.
Why? Because they know that these dollars are the best-spent dollars an organization can make. The returns from these investments far outstrip the impact of dollars saved by underfunding their investment opportunities.
Public education is no different. It's ludicrous to argue where in the bottom half of education investment we are. The goal is a simple one: We should be at the top with respect to our investment in the education of our children. California is the wealthiest, most successful, and simultaneously one of the most expensive states to live in in the country. We should be investing more in our children's education than virtually any other state — and it's worth noting that a dollar spent here has, in some cases, only a third the impact it has in lower-cost areas of the country.
Education is our society's research and development department. Educated, motivated kids bring many benefits to our society. It's worth mentioning two critical ones: higher lifetime earnings are strongly correlated with higher educational achievement, thus increasing the wealth of our society and providing "payback" for taxpayers' educational investment. Also, most research indicates a strong correlation between low education and anti-social behavior, suggesting that educated kids commit less crime and, by extension, cost us less in terms of our legal and criminal systems.
Currently the Newhall School District receives about $4,700 per year per pupil from all sources to educate our kids, or about $25 per classroom day.
Compare this to the national average for public schools, which is over $6,100 per year per pupil, to states such as Connecticut which spend over $8,000 per year per pupil, and the national average for non-sectarian private schools which five years ago was over $6,600 per pupil per year.
While it's certainly true that money can be poorly spent — even wasted — bringing little results (think of Michael Huffington or Delino DeShields), it is equally true that, with few exceptions, the most successful organizations are those that invest the highest levels of capital in their businesses or organizations.
Leaders of all organizations have a responsibility to ensure that monies are invested wisely; that dollars are spent in the most advantageous way possible. This does not mean that every development effort is a success. Some products turn in a lackluster performance, and not every player is a superstar — some have to be traded away. But in aggregate, maximum, astutely managed investments consistently result in a stellar roster of outstanding programs, players and products.
Let's redirect our efforts from arguing how far below the 50th percentile we are in spending to educate our kids, to how quickly we can move to lead the nation. We need to encourage our governor and Legislature to invest astutely and wisely in our kids and in their and our future in accordance with our wealth and stature as the sixth-leading economy in the world.
It's the right thing to do for our kids, and for our future.
* * *
Steve Tannehill is a trustee for the Newhall School District. If you would like to write a guest column, call Tim Whyte at 259-1234, ext. 234.
