"A Scout is reverent." So says the Boy Scout Handbook.
Mixed in among all the technical books in my office bookcase, I have a Boy Scout Handbook. I have never been a Scout, but after I read in a book by the famous tracker Tom Brown that everything a person needed to know about survival could be found in the handbook, I decided to take a look, and picked up a copy at a used book store.
I'm not so sure that everything I need to know is in it, but I did find the manual worth holding on to. After all, working in the wilds of El Segundo can present unpredictable challenges.
In the last few pages of the Scouts' guidebook, following the chapters on camping, canoeing, knot tying and first aid, is a section on religious awards. These awards are not given by the Boy Scout organization, but by the individual Scout's own religious leader who also sets the requirements for earning it. Having earned such an honor, Scouts may then wear on their uniform a medallion representing their faith. The handbook has illustrations of medals from the Baptists, Catholics, Jews, Buddhists, Mormons, and others. One of those "others" is the Unitarian Universalist Church.
The UUs, as we like to call ourselves, have a long history with the Boy Scouts. Many of our churches sponsor troops. Many of our members serve as adult leaders. The president of our national organization was once a Life Scout (that's just below Eagle Scout), and as a pastor in New York City he helped establish a troop for inner-city boys. Hundreds of our youth in Scouts have been given our Religion in Life award.
But the Boy Scouts of America (BSA) is not too happy with the Unitarians lately. It seems that our teachings are not to their liking.
One issue the BSA has with the church is that "Religion in Life," the UU manual for that is the basis for our religious award, refers to the Scout organization as "secular," whereas the Scouts define themselves as "ecumenical."
This point may be merely a matter of someone in need of a dictionary, because according to Webster, the word "ecumenical" pertains only to interactions among Christian churches. "Secular" on the other hand, may be the more appropriate term to use for an organization that is not part of one particular religion but focuses instead on teaching moral values.
I suspect that the Scouts prefer to remain an interfaith group, and don't really want to exclude Jews, Muslims, Hindus and other non-Christians from membership. But they do seem to want to define themselves as a religious organization in order to justify their exclusionary membership rules.
I think the greater bone of contention for the Scout organization is that among the Unitarian Universalist religious principles is the belief that discrimination is wrong. This doesn't sit well with the Scouts, for they have a strict policy of excluding homosexuals from membership. The UUs, on the other hand, do not judge a person by their sexuality and openly welcome gays and lesbians into our churches. The fact that some of our ministers are openly gay does not distract us from their guidance on more important matters.
This conflict between the beliefs of the church and the policies of the Scouts is so considerable that it was addressed in the Religion in Life manual. A young person trying to reconcile membership in both groups needs guidance, and the church stepped up to the task.
Regardless, the BSA is ticked. So ticked that they wrote the church leaders and ordered them to stop issuing the award for religion to their Scouts. Further, Scouts are now prohibited from even wearing a religious award emblem given by the church. In essence, the Boy Scouts of America, having placed themselves in the position of sitting in judgment of other people's religious beliefs, have disavowed the Unitarian Universalist religion.
The BSA has committed religious discrimination at its worst. Prohibiting a Scout from wearing a medallion of their faith borders on religious persecution. How would you react to being told, "I'm sorry, but your religion is no longer acceptable to the Boy Scouts, so you may not wear their emblem on your uniform?"
John Buehrens, president of the Unitarian Universalist Association, responded to the Scouts' letter to the church. A most articulate man, Mr. Buehrens carefully explained the position of the church, and then, true to the Unitarian Universalist heritage of in-your-face social activism, diplomatically told the Scouts to stuff it: "We will not acquiesce in such discrimination," he wrote. "We will not stop distributing a Religion in Life manual that reflects our religious principles. We will not stop providing Religion in Life awards and Love and Help emblems to Scouts and Scout leaders. If you and the BSA honestly believe that it will promote or defend Scouting to refuse our awards or to have Scout officials tear them off the uniforms of boys, I think you are sadly mistaken. Most Americans will see such actions for what they are: blatant discrimination against children on the basis of their religion."
Amen, Mr. Buehrens, amen.
* * *
Rick Lott is president of the Democratic Alliance for Action of the SCV. If you would like to write a guest column, call Tim Whyte at 259-1234, ext. 234.
