In response to The Signal’s editorial of Aug. 4, I would like to expand on the reasons behind my decision not to accept campaign contributions from businesses or political action committees.
Mine is not an anti-business position. I work for a salary, and I know how much we all depend on industry and commerce in nearly every aspect of our lives. Nor is this a party issue, as it crosses party lines.
Rather, my position is pro-citizen .
The financing of California campaigns by special interests is completely out of control and I resolved not to accept business or PAC money in order to spotlight the need for campaign finance reform. Both parties claim to want to reform the system, but at the same time incumbents and challengers from both sides are raking in the cash at a frenzied pace.
Because California’s campaign finance laws are among the loosest in the nation, wealthy individuals, corporations and special-interest groups are able to donate to candidates and ballot measures without limit, and the one with the most cash usually wins. Knowing this, candidates woo large contributors. The problem with this chain of events is that the needs of the voters become secondary.
The welfare of the housing industry can become more important to a politician than the problem of urban sprawl. The need of a cement company for gravel can become more important than a community’s desire for clean air and water. A reduction in business taxes can become more important than a cut in personal income tax. And the list goes on.
Clearly, the system puts the average voter with limited assets at a disadvantage when it comes to vying for a politician’s attention. The solution, I believe, is to level the playing field. It’s been done at the federal level, and it can be done at the state level.
In contrast to state law, federal regulations do not permit business to donate to candidates. Employees of businesses can form PACs, but contributions are limited to $5,000 per candidate for each primary or general election. Personal contributions are limited to $1,000 per election. Limits of this nature put the maximum contribution within reach of most voters, and allow them to “compete” with larger interests.
Even with these limits, congressional candidates have no problem running enormous, viable campaigns. The difference between federal and state races, however, is that federal candidates stay in closer contact with the constituents, in order to court their votes.
So effective is this method that it even brought a U.S. senator to Santa Clarita last year. The Barbar Boxer campaign was one of the most hotly contested Senate races in the nation. Yet Sen. Boxer prevailed despite having raised only 10 percent of her funding from PACs. She won by putting the voters first.
In state races, however, the ratio of individual-to-PAC contributions can go so far as to be reversed. At the end of 1998 State Sen. Pete Knight had raised a scant 15 percent of his re-election funding from small individual donors. Keith Olberg, our neighboring assemblyman (and possible Republican challenger to Knight) financed a trifling 20 percent of his last campaign from small donors.
And yes, Democrats play the game, too. Assemblyman Anthony Cardenas, who won his 1998 race after raising a mere 9 percent of his funds from individuals, had the highest ratio of the election.
In 1996, 70 percent of the voters demonstrated their desire for campaign finance reform by voting for either Proposition 208 or 212, yet reform is not anywhere on the agendas of Knight, Runner or Olberg. If anything, these three have demonstrated their disregard for the will of the people and their preference for the status quo by inflating their coffers with hefty donations from special interests.
When Proposition 208 was set aside in federal court, it was ruled that the limits on donations were so low as to constitute an infringement on free speech, but the judge expressed the possibility that, if rewritten to allow higher limits, the proposition could stand. It was a green light for another attempt.
People vote and elect our leaders, and the process belongs in their hands. “Corporate citizenship” ends at the ballot box. Reform measures would ensure this. There are a number of campaign finance reform initiatives in the process of qualifying for the March 2000 ballot. While not endorsing one over another, I predict that the people of California will vote once again to de-claw the fat cats.
Whatever the outcome, (and should I move on to the general election) I shall let the will of the people guide my future fund-raising decisions.
Rick Lott is a Santa Clarita resident who plans to run for the Democratic nomination to the 17th Senate District.
