I am writing to add my thoughts to the discussion of the posting of the Ten Commandments in schools and other public places, which was recently voted upon in Congress and then commented upon by The Signal in a July 9 editorial.
I want to thank Nancy Vincent, who wrote a letter to the editor which pointed out that the Ten Commandments are not from
Lisa
Goldwag Kassner
Guest Commentary
Christianity, but “primarily from Judaism.” I would modify Ms. Vincent’s comments to state that the Ten Commandments are solely Jewish in origin. Our Bible, which we call the Torah, was incorporated by the Christians as the “Old Testament.” As such, the Christians have taken on the Ten Commandments as part of their own Bible.
It is interesting to note that the themes that Ms. Vincent states that Christianity emphasizes, embodied in quotes attributed to Jesus (Matt. 22: 36-39 ) about love of God (Deut. 6: 4-5 ) and neighbor (Lev. 19:18), also come directly from our Torah. Though our detractors have said that ours is a religion of “law,” our path is also one of “love” — of putting love into practice.
However, despite the Ten Commandments being from Judaism, you will find that many Jews oppose mixing religion into American law by posting them. What a fearful precedent this sets! We remember our own history— the Spanish Inquisition, Nazi Germany, and the lesser known expulsions from England, France, Italy, and other European states— in the past two millennia. For our choice of a path of life and worship different from those around us, we have suffered discrimination, disputations, forced conversions, expulsions, state-sanctioned anti-Jewish riots, and punishment by death. (In disputations, the dominant church forced a Jewish religious leader into a public debate in order to try to convince the population of the rightness of Christianity, and convert us.)
The Jews in America are very grateful for the blessings of liberty and safety that the policy of the separation of religion and state affords us. While we cherish the Ten Commandments, and they are part of a Jewish child’s religious education at home and/or in the synagogue, the passage of this kind of law sets a dangerous precedent. What will be the next step in bringing one particular religion or another into official public sanctioning?
For those whose beliefs do not include the Ten Commandments, posting such a document already crosses the line because it is not part of their religion at all. Where is the respect for their beliefs?
The Ten Commandments were added by Congress to a bill that was to reduce gun violence in response to the Littleton massacre. Perhaps the idea was that Commandment No. 6, “You shall not kill,” would be useful to have emblazoned on every available wall. But this does not appear to be a realistic solution to the thorny and complex problem of violence in our society.
It also seems unnecessary to authorize an obviously parochial sign. Respect for life is an ethical value that all people of faith, as well as affirmed atheists and secular Americans, could agree upon. Being an ethical person is something we all must learn how to do. It seems opportunistic to me that our members of Congress thought to specifically offer the Ten Commandments as part of the bill on gun violence. It was a way to open the door to getting more religion into American law. But religion is not the place of the government.
Sometimes we hear Christian religious leaders arguing that bringing religion into the public domain is justifiable because “we are a Christian nation.” I suppose they say this because they are in the majority, and because whites of Christian heritage were in control of the government at the time of the Revolution. It’s clearly not because they were here first - the Native Americans were. And there were certainly a lot of Africans here, who at least in the beginning had their own religions from their homelands. And there were also Jews and probably people of other religious backgrounds, as well.
Considering this, our Founding Fathers nevertheless did not see fit to declare a national religion. But some of today’s Christians do. It is my hope that these Christians will go back one step further and look at the roots of Christianity in the United States. The Christians who first came here had packed their bags from England and the Netherlands because they were suffering persecution and sought religious freedom. However, when they arrived, they sought to deprive others of it. (Consider, for example, the case of Roger Williams’ leaving Massachusetts to found Rhode Island.)
Perhaps Jesus’ disciple Matthew should have added a few more words from the Jewish Torah. The Torah teaches us we must have compassion for the foreigner and slave because we remember being slaves in Egypt, and compassion is the path of holiness, the path of God. Each year at the Passover Seder, we relive our roots and are reminded of the importance of compassion, even toward the oppressing Egyptians who died at God’s hand in order that we might be free.
The original Christians saw America as the new Israel, and were grateful that God had brought them to this land so that they could be free to worship as wished. It is my hope that, just as Christians have taken on love of God and love of neighbor and the Ten Commandments from our Bible, they will remember their own roots and embrace both gratitude for their freedom, and compassion for those who are not Christians by keeping church and state separate.
In this separation, may we all enjoy the freedom we have been blessed with here. Let us remember that freedom is a gift that belongs to everyone.
Lisa Goldwag Kassner is a Canyon Country resident.
