By way of introduction, I am writing this in response to Ernie Tichenor’s column titled, “Whose Ten Commandments Would We Use?” that ran on Aug 17. His column is well-thought , articulate and cogent as he tries to define the First Amendment and its application to the separation of church and state that we know today. But his understanding of the First Amendment leaves room for me to take some “liberty.”
Peter Dashnaw
So here goes.
In the last quarter of the 18th Century, there was no country in the world that governed with separate and divided powers providing checks and balances on the exercise of authority of those who governed. A first step toward such a result was taken with the Declaration of Independence in 1776, which was followed by the Constitution, drafted in Philadelphia in 1787. It had antecedents back to the Magna Carta and beyond. The work of 55 men in Philadelphia in 1787 marked the beginning of the end of the divine rights of kings.
The Bill of Rights was added in 1791. The first of these amendments contains the much-disputed Establishment Clause. Now, I’m not a constitutional lawyer or scholar. But, then neither were the framers who wrote it. They were farmers and merchants, craftsmen and clergymen. A few were lawyers of their time and a few were officials of one type or another.
But the beauty of their labor is a document that does not need interpretation or translation. With a little critical thinking, the common man easily understands it. It is a timeless document. The framers were inspired with the wisdom to craft a document solely focused on liberty. So much so that history documents that European governments were so threatened by the prospect of this form of government catching on they conspired in secrecy to bring it down. It was only their hatred for each other that kept them from fully allying.
As for the First Amendment, taken strictly in the context in which it was written, it seems clear that the Establishment Clause was never intended to restrict either government from involving itself in religion, or religion from involving itself in government. Mr. Tichenor’s contention that in order to guarantee an atmosphere of absolute religious liberty the founding fathers mandated strict separation of church and state is simply not tenable. (His taking a quote from James Madison is essentially meaningless without knowing the context from which it was given.) That interpretation comes from the U.S. Supreme Court. Although that opinion makes it law, it doesn’t make it right. Constitutional scholars disagree on a great many things. But one thing that is almost universally agreed upon is the intent of framers as they crafted a form a government called a constitutional republic, not a democracy.
We all too frequently hear the First Amendment misquoted or abridged. Yes, it does say that Congress shall make no laws respecting an establishment of religion (Hence the Establishment Clause), but the second clause all too frequently goes unheralded. It reads, “... or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.”
The very essence of liberty is the sum of rights and exemptions possessed in common by the people. Liberty by its nature does not limit the right to free exercise, but contends for it. Mr. Tichenor’s assertion that, largely because of the prohibition of church and state religious faiths flourish, flies in the face of even a rudimentary understanding of the word liberty.
The intent of the framers in creating the Establishment Clause was to prevent a recurrence of the Church of England, a state-run religion. That’s all. Remember that freedom of religion was the single biggest reason so many “pilgrims” made the dangerous voyage across the icy Atlantic to this new and very hostile land.
Regarding Mr. Tichenor’s comments about the Ten Commandments: He asks the question “whose do we use?” contending the different faiths all have different versions. Not so. Yes, the Ten Commandments are found in the Torah. But the Torah is found in the Christian Bible. The Mormons have them in their bible. Even Moslems refer to them in the Koran. The Christian Bible, whether orthodox or reformed, Catholic or Protestant, contains those same Ten Commandments, word for word. “Thou shall not steal,” is still “thou shall not steal.” What’s to interpret? (Parenthetically, stealing in a Moslem country gets your right hand chopped off.) Granted, you can have it in Hebrew, Latin, and the King James with its Shakespearean English, or you can have it in any one of several Modern English or paraphrased versions, but they all say the same thing. I don’t know of many “religions” that disagree on the interpretation of the Ten Commandments. Church leaders are more wrapped up in debating the application of doctrinal issues to today’s politically correct society to bother rehashing something so foundationally established as the Ten Commandments.
As for his contention that “freedom of religion also means freedom from religion,” in the public schools, I can only refer him to the state of California Guidelines for the Teaching about Religion in the Public Schools. He’s dead wrong. The state specifically requires schools to teach about the various religions and their contribution to society and culture. In fact, the state guidelines are so broad that they do not even prohibit the reading of the Bible in the classroom in an effort to demonstrate the forms of prose and poetry contained therein. But, that’s the written law. The unspoken rule is what prevails. Let a teacher try and stand up in a public school classroom and teach about the impact of Jesus Christ on the world and see what happens. Tolerance and diversity for the teacher go out the window as the teacher is systematically criticized, disciplined and possibly even sued. So much for “...the free exercise thereof.”
Mr. Tichenor also contends that “keeping legislators out of religious disputes has spared us the devastation seen throughout the world in countless religious conflicts and persecutions.” Here we go again with the Holy Wars. Hasn’t that dog died yet? Yes the church has skeletons in the closet. Yes, the Crusaders were bad guys. OK, I’m sorry. But, they were at least doing it for what they believed was a righteous cause. Show me a culture or people, or a religion that doesn’t have something lurking in their past. African tribal leaders sold their own people into slavery, not for an ideal, but for money. They’re still doing it today as evidenced by the atrocities going in Sudan. And let’s not forget the cultures and ideologies that have tried to abolish religion all together. We know about the Nazi Holocaust and should never forget it. But, few people acknowledge the tens of million who died under the heavy-handed Soviet regimes of Lenin and Stalin as they sought to obliterate religion all together.
One last thought: Mr. Tichenor asserts that a relationship with God is personal. I don’t know the context of his thinking. But, don’t expect me to be personal about my relationship with God. Public proclamation is how I’m commanded to spread the good news of my faith. We agree on one thing; I don’t want any government telling me who to, or not to worship, how when, why or where. “Free exercise thereof...” is my liberty, and I claim it.
Peter Dashnaw is a Santa Clarita resident.
