I apologize for the headline. The Signal had nothing to do with this bit of subterfuge. The reason for this ploy is that, today, I would like to discuss something that causes most people to avert their eyes and turn the page. Water politics. This is important, though. Something is going on in the Santa Clarita Valley that does not pass the smell test.
Water and water rights have historically been very important, more so in the West and in California. Since the first settlers came over the Rocky Mountains, the control of water has meant wealth and the control of power. This has not changed in 150 years. The story of William Mulholland and the L.A. Aqueduct is a classic example of hardball water politics. Ranchers in the Owens Valley were duped into selling water rights to the city of Los Angeles. Wealthy insiders, like the Chandlers, made fortunes buying San Fernando Valley land at rock-bottom prices, only to see values skyrocket when the Owens Valley water finally came pouring over the Newhall Pass. Recently, Santa Clarita has had its very own “Chinatown.” Vast sums of money have changed hands. Power was usurped from publicly elected directors and handed over to individuals with their own secret agendas.
The Castaic Lake Water Agency is a water wholesaler. Its job is to buy water and then resell it to our local water retailers. The Santa Clarita Water Co. is one of the water retailers, serving Canyon Country and the east side of the valley. SCWC was, until recently, privately owned by a single family, the Bonnellis. On Sept. 3, the CLWA purchased the SCWC for $63 million of taxpayer money. What is wrong with that, you ask? Allow me to explain (I’ll try not to be dry and boring).
Two years ago the SCWC’s value was appraised at $10 million. Last year the city of Santa Clarita considered purchasing this water retailer for $40 million. This month, the CLWA purchased the SCWC for $63 million, cash money, up front. This is a transfer of an enormous amount of taxpayer money into the hands of a single Santa Clarita family.
Where did this money come from? The CLWA controlled $75 million from a bond measure, passed to upgrade the main water lines to the east side of the valley. After the money was raised, the directors of the CLWA simply sent a letter to the bond trustee and said, in effect, “We changed our minds, we are buying a water company instead.” That money is now gone forever.
Why does the CLWA need a water retailer? One of the chief considerations in the approval of new developments is the availability of water supplies to serve them. The CLWA has done an excellent job representing the developers’ interests. They own over $40 million worth of “paper” water. What I mean by this is that they have purchased water rights from the state, for Northern California water. We don’t actually have that water, only a promise to deliver it, if it is available. In times of drought or if an earthquake disrupts the water delivery system (remember, the California aqueduct runs parallel to the San Andreas Fault), we will receive no water at all from the state system. In that case, groundwater availability becomes very important. Developers must show adequate emergency supplies to obtain approval of new developments.
CLWA had no access to groundwater, but the SCWC owns extensive groundwater rights in the Santa Clarita Valley. This then, is why it was important enough to a majority on the CLWA board to take $63 million earmarked for capital improvements and spend it to buy a $10 million water company. Now groundwater that formerly would have been available to SCWC customers in times of emergency is pledged to the new developments west of the freeway, including the 25,000 homes of Newhall Ranch. It’s only my opinion, but something is very wrong with this.
However, as long as water flows when the tap is turned on, most people tend to be content. Unfortunately, the politics of water are of interest only to a small minority of powermongers, business interests and political junkies.
What can we do about this? A lawsuit has been filed by four members of the community, led by Lynne Plambeck, a longtime community activist, environmentalist and water consultant (deemed so by a court of law).
Their lawsuit seeks to overturn this questionable purchase of SCWC by the Castaic Lake Water Agency. Unfortunately for the average water customer, the lawsuit was dismissed by the first judge to hear the case. The lawsuit will be appealed, but I fear this may amount to tilting at windmills.
Business- and developer-backed candidates are now the majority on our City Council, local water boards and the CLWA. The only way to change this is with a ballot. The people need to vote for candidates who will protect their interests. An uninformed, non-voting electorate is the greatest danger to a democracy, as evidenced by the $63 million boondoggle foisted upon the taxpayers by the CLWA.
Water politics may not be interesting, but it will always be important.
Kevin Buck is a Santa Clarita resident. “Those Damn Democrats” appears Tuesdays, and rotates among several local Democrats.
