When a developer attempts to gain approval for a controversial project, its credibility is key. Public statements about the development, especially those made to a government agency, must be completely truthful— and tell the whole truth.
Sadly, this has not been the case with Southdown Corp.’s proposed 78-million-ton Transit Mixed Concrete gravel mine in Soledad Canyon, just outside of the Santa Clarita city boundaries in my district.
This project is highly controversial, based on concerns about noise, traffic, air pollution, water and economic impacts that are expected to occur as a result of the mining. This is why I joined all of the local governmental agencies and private groups in the Santa Clarita Valley, including the City Council, in strongly opposing the project.
As is the case with any matter that has environmental impacts, I believe decisions about this project should be based on sound science, community consensus and a careful examination of the facts. With this in mind, I was highly disappointed with an Aug. 29 presentation Southdown officials made to the Santa Clarita City Council.
With the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors scheduled on Oct. 24 to hear Southdown’s appeal of the county Regional Planning Commission’s 5-0 vote rejecting Southdown’s application, this meeting was supposed to have been an opportunity for Southdown to reach out to the community with some straight talk about the project.
During this meeting, Randy Thompson, an attorney, testified for Southdown regarding the federal and local government role in this project, in light of the fact that the proposed mining is pursuant to a contract that Southdown signed with the federal Bureau of Land Management.
During its presentation to the City Council, Southdown officials claimed that federal law prevents local governments, such as Los Angeles County, from rejecting this mining operation. In essence, Southdown was stating that local approval of the project was not a legal necessity.
Finally, they stated that all that was truly needed was BLM’s go-ahead .
What Southdown did not explain thoroughly, honestly and without hesitation was that the executive summary of the record of decision by the BLM on this project states without question that Southdown must obtain the local permits and lists the Los Angeles County supervisors, among several other agencies, as a necessary hurdle. Regardless of whether Southdown wants to quibble over what the county can or cannot do to limit this action, the clear language of the record of decision and the contract signed by Southdown states that Southdown must obtain these permits.
In fact, the BLM has put this requirement in writing even more explicitly. In its official response to a petition to stay of the project pending an internal BLM appeals process, the BLM’s attorney wrote on Sept. 11: “Transit Mixed Concrete (TMC), the project operator, must obtain several other permits or authorizations required by law as one of the conditions of approval... TMC is legally required to have an approved Surface Mining and Reclamation Plan (SMARA Plan) from the County of Los Angeles before any actual mining can begin.”
When Southdown officials have either spoken to my staff or myself they have repeatedly stated they want to be good neighbors in this community. They claim they recognize that if they are to do business in this valley for decades to come, they must be good neighbors to the community.
If this is in fact the case, they must do an improved job of telling the truth, the whole truth, and not leave any detail out. The people of this valley deserve that.
U.S. Rep. Howard P. “Buck” McKeon, R-Santa Clarita, represents the 25th District, which includes the Santa Clarita, Antelope and northern San Fernando valleys.
