In the national debate between presidential candidates Al Gore and George W. Bush, two very different visions of America were presented.
Gore faithfully spewed out his party line, offering more welfare and government hand-outs to “ middle-class America,” who he claimed is the backbone of our country, the ones who work and sweat to earn their living. He repeatedly harped on Bush’s intention to give tax breaks to the “wealthy 1 percent” and accused Bush of neglecting those who really need and deserve assistance.
Basically, Gore’s strategically planned choice of lingo was specifically designed to make our hearts bleed for the poor and needy and turn a spiteful eye toward the gluttonous rich.
Well, let me point out a few facts that may shed some light on his tactics.
The pressing question is, who is “middle class America”? And who are these “wealthy 1 percent” we keep hearing so much about?
According to the 1997 United States Housing Survey, the median annual income for Americans is $33,000. The average American earns between $20,000 to $59,000 per year. Anything over that is considered upper class. And anything over $120,000 a year is wealthy.
In fact, this survey lumps all incomes over $120,000 into one category and the percentage is indeed rather small.
Citizens of Santa Clarita, do you consider yourself wealthy?
Anyone who lives in Southern California knows full well that $59,000 a year is not even enough to buy a house in any decent neighborhood unless of course you are willing to commute two hours each way to work. My brother is a successful accountant working in the San Fernando Valley, yet he and his wife and three children still live in a two-bedroom apartment because they can’t scrape together enough for a down payment and can’t qualify for a loan large enough to buy a home anywhere near his employment.
Gore believes the wealthy do not deserve a tax break. Funny, but our family’s single income easily fits into his idea of wealthy, yet my grocery budget is often not enough to get us through between paychecks, my husband’s shoes have a crack in the sole, he owns only one suit, and I love to shop at secondhand children’s clothing stores.
My husband works 40 hours a week in Downtown Los Angeles just to pay the bills and make ends meet. We are truly grateful for what we have and feel fortunate that his income allows me to stay home with our young children. But wealthy? I think if anyone deserves a tax break it’s us and every other “wealthy” American who is required to pay a larger portion and percentage of his hard-earned income to the government than any other segment of the population.
Bush’s plan for tax cuts is fair and a long time in coming. If Gore wins this election it will be because he has succeeded in pitting class against class and convincing the “middle class” that they are suffering at the hands of the filthy rich. He will have craftily led them to believe that their only hope of rescue is more government hand-outs , which, of course, can only be funded by taxing the wealthy.
I hope instead that Americans in all income brackets will use their heads and think this through. Bush’s plan is simply smarter and will benefit the largest percentage of Americans. It just makes sense.
Laurisa White Reyes is a Santa Clarita resident.
